Lecomte D, Fornes P, Nicolas G
Department of Forensic Sciences, University of Paris (V), France.
Forensic Sci Int. 1996 May 17;79(1):1-10. doi: 10.1016/0379-0738(95)01873-5.
The reports relating emotional stress to sudden death are largely anecdotal. In addition to experimental and electrophysiological studies, an opportunity for a better understanding of possible stress-related sudden death (SSD) may be provided by medicolegal autopsies. The goal of our autopsy study was to analyze cardiovascular pathologic findings in cases of SSD and if possible identify mechanisms by which the stressful event (SE) could be the cause. Forty three cases were studied (29 males and 14 females). In all cases, the SE and the death were witnessed. The age range was 22 to 90 years in males (mean, 52) and 30 to 92 years in females (mean, 64). Death occurred in all cases without premonitory symptoms. In 20 cases, death occurred during the SE and in the other 23 cases occurred within 2 h of the event. SE included fear, 15 cases; altercation, 21 cases; sexual activity, 3 cases; police questioning or arrest, 4 cases. According to police reports, in 40 cases (90%), the victims had no previous clinical history of cardiovascular disease. At autopsy, the heart weight in males ranged from 255 to 1000 g with a mean of 517 g and in females the range was 250-700 g with a mean of 417 g. In only 3 cases, gross and microscopic examination of the heart was normal. In 2 of the remaining 40 cases the subjects died of subarachnoid hemorrhage. In 38 cases, a cardiac cause of death was found as follows: coronary heart disease, 27 cases; cardiomyopathy, 6 cases; aortic valvular stenosis, 2 cases and right ventricular dysplasia, 3 cases. A coronary artery thrombosis was found in 8 cases of sudden coronary death. Post myocardial infarction fibrosis was present in 25 cases (92%) of sudden coronary death. In conclusion, it appears from our autopsy study that SSD occurs primarily in those individuals with severe heart disease, especially coronary heart disease.
将情绪应激与猝死相关的报告大多属于轶事性的。除了实验和电生理研究外,法医尸检可能为更好地理解可能与应激相关的猝死(SSD)提供一个机会。我们尸检研究的目的是分析SSD病例中的心血管病理发现,并尽可能确定应激事件(SE)可能成为死因的机制。研究了43例病例(29例男性和14例女性)。所有病例中,SE和死亡情况均有目击。男性年龄范围为22至90岁(平均52岁),女性为30至92岁(平均64岁)。所有病例死亡时均无前兆症状。20例在SE期间死亡,另外23例在事件发生后2小时内死亡。SE包括恐惧15例;争吵21例;性活动3例;警方讯问或逮捕4例。根据警方报告,40例(90%)受害者既往无心血管疾病临床病史。尸检时,男性心脏重量范围为255至1000克,平均517克,女性范围为250至700克,平均417克。仅3例心脏大体和显微镜检查正常。其余40例中有2例死于蛛网膜下腔出血。38例发现心脏死因如下:冠心病27例;心肌病6例;主动脉瓣狭窄2例;右心室发育不良3例。8例冠状动脉猝死病例发现冠状动脉血栓形成。25例(92%)冠状动脉猝死病例存在心肌梗死后纤维化。总之,从我们的尸检研究来看,SSD主要发生在患有严重心脏病,尤其是冠心病的个体中。