Reboul F, Brewer Y, Vincent P, Chauvet B, Faure C F, Taulelle M
Department of Radiation Therapy, Clinique Sainte Catherine, Avignon, France.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1996 May 1;35(2):343-50. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(96)00087-9.
Prognosis of unresectable Stage III nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) treated with thoracic radiotherapy alone has been disappointing. In recent years, several Phase III trials have demonstrated encouraging results with induction chemotherapy, but with poor long-term local control. Concurrent cisplatin alone during the radiation therapy course has resulted in improved local control, but without efficacy on occult metastatic disease. Intensification of chemotherapy during radiation has the potential of improving both local control and metastasis-free survival. This Phase II study was undertaken to determine the feasibility, toxicity, response rate, local control, and survival of concurrent chemotherapy with cisplatin-etoposide and radiotherapy in unresectable Stage IIIA and IIIB nonsmall cell lung cancer.
Between February 1992 and April 1993, 50 patients with either medically or technically inoperable Stage III NSCLC were treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy. Thoracic radiotherapy was administered to a total dose of 60 Gy. Concurrent chemotherapy consisted of cisplatin 20 mg/m2/day plus etoposide 50 mg/m2/day, from day 1 through day 5, every 4 weeks for four cycles. Medically operable patients were evaluated for surgical resection after 45 Gy and two cycles of concurrent chemotherapy. All patients received an esophagitis preventive regimen.
Response rate was 84%, including 68% complete response. With a minimum follow-up of 23 months, overall survival was 70% at 1 year, 39.7% at 2 years, and 34.7% at 3 years. Median survival was 18 months. Age, performance status, histologic type and grade, and stage and tumor size, did not influence survival, with the exception of contralateral nodal involvement (p = 0.0055). Patients achieving a complete response (n = 34) had a 2-year survival of 58.4% compared to 0% for nonresponders (p < 0.0001). Patients who could benefit from surgery (n = 9) had a 2-year survival of 77.8% compared to 31.2% for nonoperated patients (p < 0.013). Seventeen patients (34%) are currently alive and free of disease. Actuarial local control was 63.4% at 1 year, and 58.5% at 2 and 3 years, respectively. Major hematologic toxicity occurred in 24% of the patients.
Concomitant chemoradiotherapy with cisplatin and etoposide at this dose level is a well tolerated outpatient regimen, which resulted in a high local control rate, and an encouraging survival at 1, 2, and 3 years. A direct comparison of this treatment schedule to induction chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy, or concurrent chemoradiation therapy using cisplatin alone, appears warranted.
单纯胸部放疗治疗不可切除的Ⅲ期非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)的预后一直不尽人意。近年来,多项Ⅲ期试验显示诱导化疗取得了令人鼓舞的结果,但长期局部控制效果不佳。放疗期间单纯使用顺铂同步治疗可改善局部控制,但对隐匿性转移疾病无效。放疗期间强化化疗有可能改善局部控制和无转移生存期。本Ⅱ期研究旨在确定顺铂-依托泊苷同步化疗联合放疗在不可切除的ⅢA期和ⅢB期非小细胞肺癌中的可行性、毒性、缓解率、局部控制率和生存率。
1992年2月至1993年4月,50例因医学或技术原因无法手术的Ⅲ期NSCLC患者接受了同步放化疗。胸部放疗总剂量为60Gy。同步化疗方案为顺铂20mg/m²/天加依托泊苷50mg/m²/天,从第1天至第5天,每4周重复一次,共四个周期。对于医学上可手术的患者,在给予45Gy放疗和两个周期同步化疗后评估手术切除的可能性。所有患者均接受食管炎预防方案。
缓解率为84%,其中完全缓解率为68%。最短随访23个月,1年总生存率为70%,2年为39.7%,3年为34.7%。中位生存期为18个月。年龄、体能状态、组织学类型和分级、分期和肿瘤大小均不影响生存率,但对侧淋巴结受累情况除外(p = 0.0055)。达到完全缓解的患者(n = 34)2年生存率为58.4%,未缓解患者为0%(p < 0.0001)。能够从手术中获益的患者(n = 9)2年生存率为77.8%,未手术患者为31.2%(p < 0.013)。17例患者(34%)目前仍存活且无疾病。1年、2年和3年的精算局部控制率分别为63.4%、58.5%和58.5%。24%的患者出现了严重血液学毒性。
在该剂量水平下,顺铂和依托泊苷同步放化疗是一种耐受性良好的门诊治疗方案,可带来较高的局部控制率,且1年、2年和3年生存率令人鼓舞。有必要将该治疗方案与诱导化疗后放疗或单纯使用顺铂同步放化疗进行直接比较。