Ismail A I, Messer J G
Faculty of Dentistry, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
J Public Health Dent. 1996 Winter;56(1):22-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-7325.1996.tb02390.x.
In December 1991 the residents of the community of Rigolet, Labrador, Canada, discovered that they were exposed to higher than 2.0 ppm fluoride in the drinking water from the new town well, which became operational in December 1983. In 1993 an investigation of the occurrence of fluorosis in children exposed to the high-fluoride water during different ages of life was carried out.
A dental examination for fluorosis was conducted using Pendrys' Fluorosis Risk Index. Out of 84 students in Rigolet, 74 were examined and the parents of 60 students agreed to be interviewed. Out of the 60 students, 48 lived all of their first six years of life in Rigolet.
Of the 48 children with life-long residence, the odds ratio of fluorosis on enamel zones that began forming during the first year of life was 8.31 (95% CI = 1.84, 38.59) for children exposed since birth or during the first year of life relative to those exposed after 1 year of age. The odds that a child had a maxillary central incisor with fluorosis were 5.69 (95% CI = 1.34, 24.15) times higher if exposure occurred during the first yea of life compared with exposure after 1 year of age. Only those exposed to the high-fluoride water during the first year of life developed fluorosis on the mandibular central incisors.
Within the limitations of this small population study, age relative to the date when the new water well became operational was a significant risk factor in development of fluorosis. The first year of life was a significant period for developing fluorosis on the mandibular and maxillary central incisors.
1991年12月,加拿大拉布拉多地区里戈莱特社区的居民发现,他们从1983年12月开始使用的新城镇水井中获取的饮用水中氟化物含量高于2.0 ppm。1993年,针对在不同年龄段接触高氟水的儿童中氟中毒的发生情况展开了一项调查。
采用彭德里斯氟中毒风险指数进行氟中毒的牙科检查。在里戈莱特的84名学生中,74名接受了检查,60名学生的家长同意接受访谈。在这60名学生中,48名在里戈莱特度过了他们生命的头六年。
在这48名终生居住在此的儿童中,自出生或出生后第一年就接触氟化物的儿童,其在生命第一年开始形成的牙釉质区域出现氟中毒的比值比为8.31(95%置信区间=1.84,38.59),相较于1岁后接触氟化物的儿童。如果在生命的第一年接触氟化物,儿童上颌中切牙出现氟中毒的几率比1岁后接触氟化物的情况高5.69倍(95%置信区间=1.34,24.15)。只有在生命第一年接触高氟水的儿童下颌中切牙出现了氟中毒。
在这项小范围人群研究的局限性内,相对于新水井投入使用的时间而言,年龄是氟中毒发生的一个重要风险因素。生命的第一年是下颌和上颌中切牙发生氟中毒的重要时期。