Madridejos R, Cabezas C, Flor F
CAP Just Oliveras, L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, Barcelona.
Aten Primaria. 1996 Apr 15;17(6):408-10.
To find the percentage of pages of advertising in 6 Spanish medical journals and compare their principal features with the criteria of the international committee of editors of medical journals.
A descriptive crossover study.
The Spanish general medical journals with the highest circulation.
All the issues of journals published between January and March 1993 (n = 56) were selected in order to calculate the average percentage of advertising. To analyse the adverts, all the adverts in 32 issues (n = 657) were selected by means of stratified random sampling of journals from the period July 1992 to June 1993.
The average number of advertising pages was 39.16%. 7.8% were publicity articles with or without an advertisement. Adverts filled the best pages of the journals. In 11.7% of cases the adverts were connected with articles in the journal; in 23.9% they were inserted within article. 13.4% of the adverts analysed were for drug products with doubtful or nil intrinsic value; and 34.5% were pharmaceutical novelties (marketed after 1991). The therapeutic groups with most advertisements were ACE inhibitors (13.2%), analgesics (7.8%), calcium antagonists (7.2%) and AINE (7.2%). Paracetamol (6.1%) was the active principal advertised most often.
The percentage of advertising seems excessive in all the journals except one and very much above the non-advertising informative material. There should be improvement by bringing journals into line with international editorial criteria.
确定6种西班牙医学期刊中广告页面的比例,并将其主要特征与国际医学期刊编辑委员会的标准进行比较。
描述性交叉研究。
西班牙发行量最大的综合医学期刊。
选取1993年1月至3月出版的所有期刊(n = 56)以计算广告的平均比例。为分析广告,通过对1992年7月至1993年6月期间的期刊进行分层随机抽样,选取了32期期刊中的所有广告(n = 657)。
广告页面的平均数量为39.16%。7.8%为有或无广告的宣传文章。广告占据了期刊的最佳页面。11.7%的情况下广告与期刊中的文章相关;23.9%的广告插入在文章之中。所分析的广告中有13.4%是关于内在价值可疑或无内在价值的药品;34.5%是药品新品(1991年后上市)。广告最多的治疗组是血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂(13.2%)、镇痛药(7.8%)、钙拮抗剂(7.2%)和非甾体抗炎药(7.2%)。对乙酰氨基酚(6.1%)是广告宣传最多的活性成分。
除一本期刊外,所有期刊的广告比例似乎都过高,且远高于非广告信息材料。应使期刊符合国际编辑标准以进行改进。