Perng D S, Jan C M, Wang W M, Chen L T, Su Y C, Liu G C, Lin H J, Huang T J, Chen C Y
Department of Internal Medicine, Kaohsiung Medical College, Taiwan ROC.
J Formos Med Assoc. 1996 May;95(5):378-85.
In a prospective study from November 1989 to December 1993, the accuracy of computed tomography (CT), endoscopic ultrasonography (EUS) and intraoperative surgical assessment were compared for the evaluation of the depth of invasion (T category) and involvement of lymph nodes (N category) in patients with gastric carcinoma. Sixty-nine consecutive patients who received preoperative CT and EUS underwent subsequent surgery. CT and EUS results were compared with histopathologic staging of tumor invasion depth and regional lymph node metastasis (pT and pN categories). T categories were staged correctly in 42% of the cases by CT, 71% by EUS and 55% by intraoperative surgical assessment. CT correctly staged 49% of N1 and N2 lymph nodes compared with 65% for EUS and 45% for intraoperative surgical assessment. CT was more accurate for advanced cancer but had a tendency to understage the T and N categories. EUS was more accurate for serosal cancer and displayed a tendency to overstage T categories and understage N categories. Intraoperative surgical assessment overstaged early T stages, understaged the T4 stage and had a tendency to overstage N categories. CT and intraoperative surgical assessment of T and N categories were of limited value in the staging of gastric carcinoma compared to EUS. EUS is a valuable form of assessment to evaluate gastric cancer staging before surgery.
在一项从1989年11月至1993年12月的前瞻性研究中,对计算机断层扫描(CT)、内镜超声检查(EUS)和术中手术评估在评估胃癌患者浸润深度(T分期)和淋巴结受累情况(N分期)方面的准确性进行了比较。69例连续接受术前CT和EUS检查的患者随后接受了手术。将CT和EUS的结果与肿瘤浸润深度和区域淋巴结转移的组织病理学分期(pT和pN分期)进行比较。CT对T分期的正确分期率为42%,EUS为71%,术中手术评估为55%。CT对N1和N2淋巴结的正确分期率为49%,而EUS为65%,术中手术评估为45%。CT对进展期癌症更准确,但有低估T和N分期的倾向。EUS对浆膜癌更准确,有高估T分期和低估N分期的倾向。术中手术评估高估了早期T分期,低估了T4期,并有高估N分期的倾向。与EUS相比,CT和术中对T和N分期的手术评估在胃癌分期中的价值有限。EUS是术前评估胃癌分期的一种有价值的方式。