Foulk R A, Steiger R M
Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, University of California, San Francisco 94143, USA.
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1996 Jul;175(1):90-6. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9378(96)70256-9.
The purpose of this study was to analyze the cost for hospital-based services related to the operative management of ectopic pregnancies and determine the most cost-conscious approach by distinguishing the constituent components.
This is a retrospective comparative review of every ectopic pregnancy that was surgically managed at the Memorial Medical Center of Long Beach. Unit cost estimates that are based on a cost accounting system were derived and compared between different procedures according to resources used among separate services.
Hemodynamic instability significantly increases the cost of management by increasing the length of stay and laboratory costs. Among stable patients laparoscopic excision of ectopic pregnancies saves nearly 25% per case (p < 0.001) compared with laparotomy. However, when we compared all intended laparoscopic excisions (i.e., including the 21% of cases in which laparotomy was eventually done), the savings were markedly reduced. In addition, the cost savings was lost if patients undergoing laparotomy were discharged on or before postoperative day 2. Discharging patients after laparotomy on postoperative day 1 is the least costly management for operative treatment of ectopic pregnancy.
Whereas laparoscopy may decrease recuperation time and incisional scarring, operative cost is not a significant reason to choose laparoscopy over laparotomy in a hemodynamically stable patient, especially as postoperative stays decrease.
本研究旨在分析与异位妊娠手术管理相关的医院服务成本,并通过区分构成要素来确定最具成本效益的方法。
这是一项对长滩纪念医疗中心接受手术治疗的每例异位妊娠进行的回顾性比较研究。根据成本核算系统得出单位成本估计值,并根据不同服务中使用的资源在不同手术之间进行比较。
血流动力学不稳定会因住院时间延长和实验室成本增加而显著提高管理成本。在病情稳定的患者中,与开腹手术相比,腹腔镜切除异位妊娠每例可节省近25%(p<0.001)。然而,当我们比较所有计划进行的腹腔镜切除术(即包括最终进行开腹手术的21%的病例)时,节省的费用明显减少。此外,如果开腹手术患者在术后第2天或之前出院,节省的成本就会丧失。开腹手术后第1天出院是异位妊娠手术治疗中成本最低的管理方式。
虽然腹腔镜检查可能会减少恢复时间和切口瘢痕,但在血流动力学稳定的患者中,手术成本并不是选择腹腔镜检查而非开腹手术的重要理由,尤其是随着术后住院时间的减少。