McCrady B S, Langenbucher J W
Center of Alcohol Studies, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ, USA.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1996 Aug;53(8):737-46. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1996.01830080091014.
After reviewing the empirical literature, we suggest that advances in the assessment and treatment of alcohol problems have the following important implications for health care system reform: (1) alcohol use disorders and problems associated with alcohol use are prevalent and are complicated by various comorbid conditions, and they result in large costs to the health care system and to society; (2) alcohol treatment generally results in reduced drinking and more efficient use of health care resources; (3) specific treatments have demonstrated effectiveness; (4) screening and assessment instruments with excellent sensitivity to the heterogeneity of alcohol problems have been developed; (5) evidence that specific treatments have differential effectiveness with different patients groups is accumulating; and (6) good evidence exists for the effectiveness of brief interventions, particularly with less severe and chronic alcohol problems. These findings suggest that alcohol treatment services in a reformed health care system should include (1) universal coverage for alcohol treatment, including full benefits for outpatient care; (2) a rational system of assessment and triage for treatment, including an increased emphasis on screening and brief interventions in primary medical care settings; (3) a full range of treatment services that vary in intensity; and (4) addictions treatment provider incentives and contingencies to provide treatments of proven effectiveness. When fully implemented, an efficient approach to the treatment of alcohol-related problems will result in one of the largest pools of cost savings in a reformed American health care system.
在回顾实证文献后,我们认为酒精问题评估与治疗方面的进展对医疗保健系统改革具有以下重要意义:(1)酒精使用障碍及与酒精使用相关的问题普遍存在,且因各种共病情况而变得复杂,它们给医疗保健系统和社会带来了巨大成本;(2)酒精治疗通常会减少饮酒,并更有效地利用医疗保健资源;(3)特定治疗方法已证明有效;(4)已开发出对酒精问题异质性具有出色敏感性的筛查和评估工具;(5)关于特定治疗方法对不同患者群体具有不同疗效的证据正在积累;(6)有充分证据表明简短干预有效,尤其是针对不太严重和慢性的酒精问题。这些发现表明,改革后的医疗保健系统中的酒精治疗服务应包括:(1)酒精治疗的全民覆盖,包括门诊护理的全部福利;(2)合理的治疗评估和分诊系统,包括在初级医疗保健环境中更加强调筛查和简短干预;(3)一系列强度各异的治疗服务;(4)对成瘾治疗提供者的激励措施和意外情况,以提供已证明有效的治疗。全面实施后,一种高效的酒精相关问题治疗方法将成为美国改革后的医疗保健系统中最大的成本节约来源之一。