Ringel S P, Vickrey B G, Rogstad T L
University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, USA.
Neurology. 1996 Jul;47(1):279-87. doi: 10.1212/wnl.47.1.279.
Because the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) exists to represent the views and needs of neurologists, a mailed survey to a randomly selected sample of 520 US-based, board-certified or board-eligible neurologist members was conducted in early 1995 to determine their attitudes in four key changing areas of the US health care system: (1) provision of neurologic care, (2) neurology workforce, (3) academic research, industry sponsorship, and pharmaceutical issues, and (4) health care delivery systems issues. Frequency distributions of degree of agreement and disagreement with 40 statements regarding issues in these four areas were tabulated for the entire group of 430 respondents (response rate = 83%). Associations between these attitudes and six demographic and practice variables (age, gender, board certification, practice type, degree of managed care, and geographical region) were evaluated in an exploratory analysis. The high response rate to the survey and the similarity in demographic and practice characteristics of respondents to the entire US-based, board-certified or -eligible AAN membership support that the attitudes that were measured are likely to be representative of US neurologists, excluding resident trainees. The survey results show that neurologists are deeply concerned that patients with chronic neurologic disorders are not receiving all the neurologic services they need. Respondent show uncertainty about whether there is a current oversupply of neurologists but generally agree that there are too many neurology residency positions. Neurologists support industry sponsorship of academic medical center research and new drug development. With respect to many of the current mechanisms for health care cost containment, respondents indicate they have little confidence that these strategies are in the best interests of patients or physicians. The survey results confirm that there is no consensus among US neurologists on how to improve today's health care delivery system, and the results suggest that certain attitudes are related to neurologists' demographic and practice characteristics. Since today's health care market is volatile, regular assessments of neurologists' attitudes will be needed to assure that their views are understood and clearly represented by the AAN.
由于美国神经病学学会(AAN)的存在是为了代表神经科医生的观点和需求,1995年初对520名美国本土、具有委员会认证资格或符合委员会资格要求的神经科医生会员进行了随机抽样邮寄调查,以确定他们对美国医疗保健系统四个关键变化领域的态度:(1)神经科护理的提供;(2)神经科劳动力;(3)学术研究、行业赞助和制药问题;(4)医疗保健提供系统问题。对430名受访者(回复率 = 83%)这一整个群体,就这四个领域问题的40条陈述的同意程度和不同意程度的频率分布进行了列表统计。在一项探索性分析中评估了这些态度与六个人口统计学和执业变量(年龄、性别、委员会认证、执业类型、管理式医疗程度和地理区域)之间的关联。对该调查的高回复率以及受访者与整个美国本土、具有委员会认证资格或符合委员会资格要求的AAN会员在人口统计学和执业特征方面的相似性,支持了所测量的态度可能代表美国神经科医生(不包括住院实习医生)的观点。调查结果显示,神经科医生深切关注慢性神经疾病患者未得到所需的所有神经科服务。受访者对目前神经科医生是否供过于求表示不确定,但普遍认为神经科住院医师培训岗位过多。神经科医生支持行业对学术医疗中心研究和新药开发的赞助。对于当前许多医疗保健成本控制机制,受访者表示他们对这些策略是否符合患者或医生的最佳利益信心不足。调查结果证实,美国神经科医生在如何改善当今的医疗保健提供系统方面没有达成共识,结果表明某些态度与神经科医生的人口统计学和执业特征有关。由于当今的医疗保健市场变化无常,需要定期评估神经科医生的态度,以确保AAN理解并清楚地代表他们的观点。