Musham C, Bellack J P, Graber D R, Holmes D
Environmental Hazards Assessment Program, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.
Fam Med. 1996 Jan;28(1):29-32.
The Institute of Medicine and the American College of Physicians have advocated that physicians broaden their participation in the environmental aspects of medical care. Accordingly, both organizations recommend training of future primary care physicians for greater competency in and appreciation of this area of medicine. This study assessed the present emphasis on environmental health in family practice residency programs by examining the extent program directors expect graduates to have specific competencies in environmental medicine.
A written survey was mailed to directors of all 393 family practice residency programs listed in the 1993 Directory of Family Practice Residency Programs. Respondents were asked to indicate the extent to which each of eight environmental health competencies was expected of their graduates. The list of environmental health competencies was based on the literature and on interviews with family practice educators. Perceptions about the "present" and "ideal" environmental health emphasis in their programs were also measured.
A total of 262 completed surveys were returned for a response rate of 67%. Respondents reported that they expected their graduates to have general knowledge of and competence in environmental health areas that pertain to patient care. Competencies with social and political implications were least likely to be expected. Two thirds of respondents indicated that "minimal emphasis" is presently placed on environmental health. Seventy percent indicated that the "ideal" amount of emphasis placed on this topic is "moderate."
This survey's results suggest that family practice residency program directors expect their graduates to know basic environmental health concepts and be skilled in related aspects of patient care. The development of environmental health training programs must take into account that environmental health may be viewed as a topic of secondary importance and that in most residencies, faculty expertise in this area is limited. For this reason, a self-tutoring strategy, aimed toward the educational needs of both faculty and residents, is recommended.
美国医学研究所和美国医师学院主张医生应更广泛地参与医疗保健的环境方面工作。因此,这两个组织都建议对未来的初级保健医生进行培训,以使他们在这一医学领域具备更强的能力并给予更多关注。本研究通过考察项目主任期望毕业生在环境医学方面具备特定能力的程度,评估了家庭医学住院医师培训项目目前对环境健康的重视程度。
向1993年《家庭医学住院医师培训项目名录》中列出的所有393个家庭医学住院医师培训项目的主任邮寄了一份书面调查问卷。要求受访者指出他们期望毕业生在八项环境健康能力中的每一项上达到何种程度。环境健康能力清单基于文献以及对家庭医学教育工作者的访谈。还测量了他们对所在项目中“当前”和“理想”的环境健康重视程度的看法。
共收回262份完整调查问卷,回复率为67%。受访者表示,他们期望毕业生具备与患者护理相关的环境健康领域的一般知识和能力。具有社会和政治影响的能力最不可能被期望具备。三分之二的受访者表示目前对环境健康“重视程度最低”。70%的受访者表示对该主题“理想”的重视程度是“适度”。
这项调查的结果表明,家庭医学住院医师培训项目主任期望他们的毕业生了解基本的环境健康概念,并在患者护理的相关方面具备技能。环境健康培训项目的开发必须考虑到环境健康可能被视为次要重要主题,并且在大多数住院医师培训项目中,该领域的教师专业知识有限。因此,建议采用一种针对教师和住院医师教育需求的自学策略。