Nizami S Q, Khan I A, Bhutta Z A
Department of Paediatrics, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Soc Sci Med. 1996 Apr;42(8):1133-9. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00386-x.
Observations were made of 996 encounters between children with diarrhoea and practitioners (28 paediatricians, 62 general practitioners) in Karachi, Pakistan. Oral rehydration salt (ORS) was prescribed in more than 50% of encounters by 53% of general practitioners (GPs) and 61% of paediatricians. Sixty-six percent of GPs and 50% of paediatricians prescribed antibacterials, 60% of GPs and 28% of paediatricians prescribed antidiarrhoeals and 39% of GPs and 32% of paediatricians prescribed antiamoebics in more than 30% of their encounters. Looking at all the encounters, we observed that ORS was prescribed in 52 and 51%, antibacterials in 41 and 36%, antidiarrhoeals in 48 and 29%, and antiamoebics in 26 and 22% of encounters by GPs and paediatricians, respectively, Cotrimoxazole was the most frequently prescribed antibacterial by both types of practitioners. Antidiarrhoeals were prescribed more often by GPs than by paediatricians. In 77% of their encounters, GPs dispensed drug formulations known as "mixtures' made in their own dispensing corners. The mean duration of encounters between patients and GPs was 3 +/- 2 minutes and between patients and paediatricians was 9 +/- 4 minutes. These results indicate inadequate prescription of ORS and excessive prescription of antibacterials, antidiarrhoeals and antiamoebics. Intervention strategies need to be planned to improve the prescribing practices of both groups.
在巴基斯坦卡拉奇,对996例腹泻患儿与医生(28名儿科医生、62名全科医生)的诊疗过程进行了观察。53%的全科医生和61%的儿科医生在超过50%的诊疗过程中开具了口服补液盐(ORS)。66%的全科医生和50%的儿科医生开具了抗菌药物,60%的全科医生和28%的儿科医生在超过30%的诊疗过程中开具了止泻药,39%的全科医生和32%的儿科医生在超过30%的诊疗过程中开具了抗阿米巴药。从所有诊疗过程来看,我们观察到,全科医生和儿科医生开具ORS的比例分别为52%和51%,开具抗菌药物的比例分别为41%和36%,开具止泻药的比例分别为48%和29%,开具抗阿米巴药的比例分别为26%和22%。两种类型的医生最常开具的抗菌药物都是复方新诺明。全科医生开具止泻药的频率高于儿科医生。在77%的诊疗过程中,全科医生配发了他们自己配药处配制的名为“合剂”的药物制剂。患者与全科医生诊疗过程的平均时长为3±2分钟,与儿科医生诊疗过程的平均时长为9±4分钟。这些结果表明ORS的处方不足,而抗菌药物、止泻药和抗阿米巴药的处方过量。需要制定干预策略以改善两组医生的处方行为。