Battagel J M
Department of Child Dental Health, London Hospital Medical College Dental School, London, UK.
Eur J Orthod. 1996 Feb;18(1):41-54. doi: 10.1093/ejo/18.1.41.
This retrospective cephalometric study examined the facial changes brought about by treatment in 62 Class II division 1 children, using tensor analysis. Thirty-two children were treated with Fränkel appliances, whilst the remaining thirty received premolar extractions, headgear, and conventional Edgewise mechanics. Each child was matched for age and sex with an untreated individual in whom the occlusion was deemed satisfactory and the treatment changes were compared with those expected during normal development. Results indicated that vertical facial development predominated in both treated groups: this exceeded the increase expected in an untreated population . The Fränkel group exhibited the greater gain in lower face height, with changes confined almost entirely to the mandible. Effective mandibular position improved but there was no increase in body length. The incisors were more favourably positioned within the face with similar improvements in the soft tissues. Thus, although facial balance was better following a non-extraction Fränkel approach, control of the vertical dimension was inadequate. The fixed appliance group exhibited a smaller increase in lower facial height and no favourable mandibular development: maxillary retraction was the most striking skeletal alteration. By removing the traditional, fixed, superimpositional framework of the cranial base, tensor analysis highlights vertical and mandibular changes not easily detected by conventional cephalometry.
这项回顾性头影测量研究使用张量分析,检查了62例安氏II类1分类儿童在治疗后所产生的面部变化。32名儿童采用Frankel矫治器进行治疗,其余30名接受拔除前磨牙、戴头帽以及传统方丝弓矫治技术。为每个儿童按照年龄和性别匹配一名未接受治疗且咬合情况令人满意的个体,并将治疗后的变化与正常发育过程中预期的变化进行比较。结果表明,两个治疗组均以上下方向的面部发育为主:这种发育超过了未治疗人群预期的增长幅度。Frankel组在下颌面部高度方面的增加更为显著,变化几乎完全局限于下颌骨。有效下颌位置得到改善,但下颌体长没有增加。切牙在面部的位置更为有利,软组织也有类似改善。因此,尽管采用非拔牙的Frankel矫治方法后面部平衡更好,但对垂直方向的控制并不充分。固定矫治器组下颌面部高度的增加较小,且下颌未出现有利的发育:上颌后缩是最显著的骨骼改变。通过去除颅底传统的、固定的、叠加式框架,张量分析突出了传统头影测量不易检测到的垂直和下颌变化。