Yoshino A, Kato M
Komagino Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1995 Dec;19(6):1517-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.1995.tb01016.x.
We studied the influence of the social desirability response set on self-reporting by alcoholics on the outcome of treatment. Seventy-one treated alcoholics gave answers based on the social desirability scale (SDS) and 19 alcohol-related items designed to evaluate abstinence, and were diagnostically interviewed. The serum gamma-glutamyl-transpeptidase (GGT) level was used as an external standard to evaluate the validity of self-reporting. As SDS scores increased, both the rate of abstinence reported by the subjects and the kappa coefficient between the self-report and diagnostic interview increased. However, the GGT level was significantly low in subjects who reported abstinence than those who reported drinking, regardless of SDS score. Thus, the social desirability response set may not be associated with a conscious response bias in alcohol-related self-reports, but may be associated with a good outcome of alcoholism.
我们研究了社会期望反应定势对酗酒者自我报告戒酒治疗结果的影响。71名接受治疗的酗酒者根据社会期望量表(SDS)和19项与酒精相关的项目进行回答,这些项目旨在评估戒酒情况,并接受了诊断性访谈。血清γ-谷氨酰转肽酶(GGT)水平用作评估自我报告有效性的外部标准。随着SDS分数的增加,受试者报告的戒酒率以及自我报告与诊断性访谈之间的kappa系数均增加。然而,无论SDS分数如何,报告戒酒的受试者的GGT水平均显著低于报告饮酒的受试者。因此,社会期望反应定势可能与酒精相关自我报告中的有意识反应偏差无关,但可能与酗酒的良好治疗结果有关。