Richardson P S, McIntyre I G
Department of Dental Health Policy, Eastman Dental Institute for Oral Health Care Sciences, London, UK.
Community Dent Health. 1996 Jun;13(2):65-9.
This paper reports on differences between the clinical and radiographic detection of caries, on both occlusal and approximal surfaces, in a cohort of Royal Air Force (RAF) recruits (mean age 18.9 years). It was found that the clinical examination detected only 30 per cent of the total lesions found by both methods combined. The radiographic examination found 201 per cent extra occlusal dentinal lesions and 192 per cent extra approximal dentinal lesions. In those recruits where caries was evident, the mean number of dentinal lesions found after the clinical examination was 1.0 compared to 2.7 lesions after the radiographic data were added. It was concluded from these results that radiographs are essential for assessment of the prevalence of both approximal and occlusal caries in service recruits. The epidemiological effect, in this age group, of the lower sensitivity of the clinical examination was to underestimate the overall DMFT by 7.8 per cent, although nearly three times as many dentinal lesions were diagnosed from radiographs as were detected clinically.
本文报告了一组皇家空军(RAF)新兵(平均年龄18.9岁)在咬合面和邻面龋的临床检测与影像学检测之间的差异。研究发现,临床检查仅检测出两种方法联合检测出的总病变的30%。影像学检查发现额外的咬合面牙本质病变占201%,额外的邻面牙本质病变占192%。在那些有明显龋齿的新兵中,临床检查后发现的牙本质病变平均数为1.0,而加入影像学数据后为2.7个病变。从这些结果得出的结论是,X光片对于评估现役新兵中邻面和咬合面龋的患病率至关重要。在这个年龄组中,临床检查较低的敏感性所产生的流行病学影响是使总体龋失补牙数(DMFT)低估了7.8%,尽管从X光片中诊断出的牙本质病变数量几乎是临床检测出数量的三倍。