Shibata T, Shibamoto Y, Sasai K, Oya N, Murata R, Takagi T, Hiraoka M, Takahashi M, Abe M
Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Kyoto University, Japan.
Br J Cancer Suppl. 1996 Jul;27:S61-4.
We investigated the cytotoxicity and the interaction with low-dose radiation (1-4Gy) of tirapazamine by the in vitro cytokinesis-block micronucleus (MN) assay. Murine SCCVII and human melanoma (G-361) cells were treated with tirapazamine under aerobic or hypoxic conditions for 1 h and the MN frequency was determined using cytochalasin-B. The cells were also treated with or without tirapazamine or KU-2285 (hypoxic cell sensitiser) under hypoxic conditions and irradiated with or without reaeration of the cell suspensions. A dose-dependent increase of MN frequency was observed by tirapazamine treatment and the hypoxic toxicity ratio was about 130 for SCCVII and 37 for G-361. The radiation dose-response curves of MN frequency suggested that the interaction of tirapazamine with irradiation appeared to be essentially additive in both cell lines. In contrast, the dose-response curve became steeper by KU-2285 treatment. Combined effects of tirapazamine and irradiation on the hypoxic cells were much higher than the radiation effect on aerobic cells at low doses, while the effects of KU-2285 did not exceed that of aerobic irradiation. In conclusion, tirapazamine appeared to be superior to hypoxic radiosensitisers at clinically relevant doses, not because of aerobic radiosensitisation but because of its potent hypoxic cytotoxicity additive to radiation effect.
我们通过体外胞质分裂阻滞微核(MN)试验研究了替拉扎明的细胞毒性及其与低剂量辐射(1 - 4Gy)的相互作用。在需氧或缺氧条件下,用替拉扎明处理小鼠SCCVII细胞和人黑色素瘤(G - 361)细胞1小时,使用细胞松弛素B测定微核频率。在缺氧条件下,细胞还分别用或不用替拉扎明或KU - 2285(缺氧细胞增敏剂)处理,并对细胞悬液进行或不进行再充氧后进行辐照。替拉扎明处理后观察到微核频率呈剂量依赖性增加,SCCVII细胞的缺氧毒性比约为130,G - 361细胞为37。微核频率的辐射剂量 - 反应曲线表明,替拉扎明与辐照的相互作用在两种细胞系中似乎基本上是相加的。相比之下,KU - 2285处理使剂量 - 反应曲线变得更陡峭。在低剂量时,替拉扎明和辐照对缺氧细胞的联合作用远高于对需氧细胞的辐射作用,而KU - 2285的作用不超过需氧辐照的作用。总之,在临床相关剂量下,替拉扎明似乎优于缺氧放射增敏剂,这不是因为其需氧放射增敏作用,而是因为其强大的缺氧细胞毒性与辐射效应相加。