Dorman P J, Sandercock P A
Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Edinburgh, Western General Hospital (Scotland).
Stroke. 1996 Sep;27(9):1507-15. doi: 10.1161/01.str.27.9.1507.
Any therapeutic trial of a new treatment for stroke must provide sufficient reliable evidence to convince clinicians and healthcare purchasers of its merits. Clinicians are most likely to be convinced by large independent studies that provide clear evidence of benefit. If the trial is really to alter healthcare delivery, it should also confirm that the treatment is cost-effective enough to satisfy the increasingly critical demands of the healthcare purchasers. Although some of the current trials will be able to detect large benefits, reliable detection of the moderate benefits that seem more plausible with neuroprotection will need to wait until completion of trials that are perhaps an order of magnitude larger. If tens of thousands of patients are to be recruited into trials of neuroprotective therapy, it is essential that the trials have simple practicable designs that allow participation not only by interested university hospitals but also busy general hospitals with few research resources.
任何针对中风新疗法的治疗试验都必须提供足够可靠的证据,以使临床医生和医疗保健购买者相信其优点。临床医生最有可能被大型独立研究所信服,这些研究能提供明确的获益证据。如果该试验真的要改变医疗保健服务的提供方式,还应证实该治疗具有足够的成本效益,以满足医疗保健购买者日益严格的要求。尽管目前的一些试验能够检测到显著的益处,但要可靠地检测出神经保护似乎更合理的适度益处,还需等待规模可能大一个数量级的试验完成。如果要招募数万名患者参与神经保护治疗试验,至关重要的是,试验要有简单可行的设计,不仅要让感兴趣的大学医院能够参与,还要让研究资源稀缺的繁忙综合医院也能参与。