Shima F, Ishido K, Sun S J, Machi T, Kamikaseda K, Fukui M, Kato M
Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan.
Eur Neurol. 1996;36 Suppl 1:55-61. doi: 10.1159/000118885.
Posteroventral pallidotomy (PVP) was carried out in 86 patients with Parkinson's disease, who presented marked bradykinesia, freezing of gait and postural defect associated with rigidity and tremor in 82 patients (bradykinesia type), and similar gait and postural problems with minimum signs of rigidity and tremor in 4 (pure akinesia type). The stereotactic coordinates of Leksell's device were calculated from MRI and conventional ventriculography. The final target was defined by microelectrode techniques in the basal ganglia. The microrecording study revealed a very high background activity in the internal pallidum in patients of the bradykinetic type, however, a much lower pallidal activity in patients of the pure akinesia type. Fifty-eight patients underwent unilateral PVP, and 28 underwent bilateral surgery. Following PVP, rigidity tremor and poor reciprocal movements were significantly improved especially in the contralateral extremities. The most dramatic findings were the reversal of akinetic symptoms and wearing-off phenomena. The patients were followed up for 3-30 months (mean = 8) after surgery. Of the 82 bradykinesia type patients, good result were obtained in 48 (58%), fair results in 26 (32%), and minor improvement or no change in 8 (10%). In all the 4 patients of the pure akinesia type, recurrence of the akinetic symptoms occurred after a temporal improvement lasting a few days to 3 month after surgery. There was worst dysarthria in 3 patients, hemiparesis in 1 and partial motor aphasia in 1. The visual field problem was not complicated in any patients. These findings suggest that akinetic symptoms in PD are implicated in overactive pallidal outputs with putative GABAergic modulator by excessively inhibiting pedunculopontine nucleus activity (midbrain locomotor and posture regions) as well as thalamic activity. Partial interruption of the pallidal efferents eliminates the akinetic symptoms by disinhibitory effects on the target structures. The pathology of PD of the pure akinesia type is supposedly in the brainstem and should be excluded from indication of pallidotomy.
对86例帕金森病患者实施了腹后苍白球切开术(PVP)。其中,82例患者表现为明显的运动迟缓、步态冻结及姿势障碍,伴有强直和震颤(运动迟缓型);4例患者有类似的步态和姿势问题,但强直和震颤症状轻微(单纯运动不能型)。根据MRI和传统脑室造影计算Leksell装置的立体定向坐标。最终靶点通过基底节微电极技术确定。微记录研究显示,运动迟缓型患者苍白球内侧的背景活动非常高,而单纯运动不能型患者的苍白球活动则低得多。58例患者接受了单侧PVP,28例接受了双侧手术。PVP术后,强直、震颤及交互运动障碍明显改善,尤其是对侧肢体。最显著的发现是运动不能症状和症状波动现象的逆转。术后对患者进行了3至30个月(平均8个月)的随访。82例运动迟缓型患者中,48例(58%)效果良好,26例(32%)效果尚可,8例(10%)改善不明显或无变化。4例单纯运动不能型患者术后均出现了运动不能症状的复发,术后短暂改善持续数天至3个月。3例患者出现严重构音障碍,1例出现偏瘫,1例出现部分运动性失语。所有患者均未出现视野问题。这些发现表明,帕金森病的运动不能症状与苍白球输出过度活跃有关,可能是由于过度抑制脚桥核活动(中脑运动和姿势区域)以及丘脑活动,通过假定的GABA能调制器所致。苍白球传出纤维的部分中断通过对靶结构的去抑制作用消除了运动不能症状。单纯运动不能型帕金森病的病理可能位于脑干,应排除在苍白球切开术的适应症之外。