Croix B S, Rak J W, Kapitain S, Sheehan C, Graham C H, Kerbel R S
Division of Cancer Biology Research, Sunnybrook Health Science Center, Reichmann Research Institute, Toronto, ON, Canada.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1996 Sep 18;88(18):1285-96. doi: 10.1093/jnci/88.18.1285.
De novo or acquired resistance to chemotherapeutic drugs continues to be one of the most important obstacles hindering the successful treatment of cancer patients. Consequently, enhancing the efficacy of conventional chemotherapeutic drugs has become an important research goal. Our previous studies using the mouse EMT-6 mammary carcinoma selected for resistance to various alkylating agents in vivo demonstrated that such acquired drug resistance may be manifested in vitro only in cells growing in a three-dimensional configuration but not in conventional monolayer culture. We also found that this phenomenon, which we refer to as "acquired multicellular resistance," is associated with an increase in intercellular adhesion or compaction of the alkylating agent-resistant cell lines grown as aggregates in three-dimensional culture.
The present study further investigates the impact of three-dimensional architecture on acquired multicellular drug resistance and its influence on cell cycle kinetics, cell cycle arrest, and cell survival.
To test the hypothesis that an increase in three-dimensional compaction is related to the drug resistance properties of the cells, we did the following: 1) selected clones of the EMT-6 cell line that spontaneously formed tightly or loosely adherent aggregates and assessed their respective drug resistance properties in vitro; 2) assayed tumorigenic potential of the tight and loose clones after exposure to defined concentrations of the activated form of cyclophosphamide, 4-hydroperoxycyclophosphamide (4-HC) in vitro; and 3) treated the tight clones with hyaluronidase, an agent capable of disrupting EMT-6 spheroids, and assayed what effect this treatment had on chemosensitivity. We used fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis to monitor any potential alterations in cell cycle kinetics.
The increase in compaction in three-dimensional culture was sufficient to confer resistance to 4-HC. This increase in intercellular adhesion was also associated with a lower proliferating fraction of tumor cells and with an almost completely diminished ability of the cells to arrest in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle after drug exposure. Furthermore, these changes were detectable only in three-dimensional culture, not in conventional monolayer culture. In conventional monolayer culture, all cell types consistently showed a high level of proliferation and arrested in G2/M after exposure to 4-HC. Moreover, hyaluronidase was able to disrupt intercellular adhesion and chemosensitize tumor cells both in vitro and in vivo in an ascites model.
Earlier studies have demonstrated that hyaluronidase is able to sensitize tumor cells to various anticancer agents. Our studies now demonstrate that this sensitization can occur by a mechanism independent of increased drug penetration. This mechanism is likely to be related to the "anti-adhesive" effect of hyaluronidase, which overrides cell contact-dependent growth inhibition, recruits cells into the cycling pool, and renders tumor cells more sensitive to cytotoxic agents that preferentially kill rapidly dividing cells.
Other tumor-specific "anti-adhesives" should be explored that can be effective chemosensitizers when used in combination with cell cycle-specific drugs for the treatment of small, solid tumors.
对化疗药物的原发性或获得性耐药仍然是阻碍癌症患者成功治疗的最重要障碍之一。因此,提高传统化疗药物的疗效已成为一个重要的研究目标。我们之前使用在体内对各种烷化剂产生耐药性的小鼠EMT-6乳腺癌进行的研究表明,这种获得性耐药可能仅在三维结构中生长的细胞中在体外表现出来,而在传统的单层培养中则不会。我们还发现,这种我们称为“获得性多细胞耐药”的现象与三维培养中作为聚集体生长的烷化剂耐药细胞系的细胞间粘附增加或紧密化有关。
本研究进一步探讨三维结构对获得性多细胞耐药的影响及其对细胞周期动力学、细胞周期停滞和细胞存活的影响。
为了检验三维紧密化增加与细胞耐药特性相关的假设,我们进行了以下操作:1)选择EMT-6细胞系中自发形成紧密或松散粘附聚集体的克隆,并在体外评估它们各自的耐药特性;2)在体外暴露于特定浓度的环磷酰胺活化形式4-氢过氧环磷酰胺(4-HC)后,测定紧密和松散克隆的致瘤潜力;3)用透明质酸酶处理紧密克隆,透明质酸酶是一种能够破坏EMT-6球体的试剂,并测定这种处理对化学敏感性的影响。我们使用荧光激活细胞分选分析来监测细胞周期动力学的任何潜在变化。
三维培养中紧密化的增加足以赋予对4-HC的耐药性。这种细胞间粘附的增加还与肿瘤细胞增殖分数降低以及药物暴露后细胞在细胞周期G2/M期停滞的能力几乎完全减弱有关。此外,这些变化仅在三维培养中可检测到,在传统单层培养中则未检测到。在传统单层培养中,所有细胞类型在暴露于4-HC后始终显示出高水平的增殖并在G2/M期停滞。此外,透明质酸酶能够破坏细胞间粘附并在体外和腹水模型的体内使肿瘤细胞对化疗敏感。
早期研究表明透明质酸酶能够使肿瘤细胞对各种抗癌药物敏感。我们现在的研究表明,这种敏感性可以通过一种独立于药物渗透增加的机制发生。这种机制可能与透明质酸酶的“抗粘附”作用有关,该作用超越细胞接触依赖性生长抑制,将细胞募集到循环池中,并使肿瘤细胞对优先杀死快速分裂细胞的细胞毒性剂更敏感。
应该探索其他肿瘤特异性“抗粘附剂”,当与细胞周期特异性药物联合用于治疗小的实体瘤时,它们可以成为有效的化疗增敏剂。