Cowan M J, Tarantal A F, Capper J, Harrison M, Garovoy M
Department of Pediatrics, University of California San Francisco 94143-1278, USA.
Bone Marrow Transplant. 1996 Jun;17(6):1157-65.
A major concern with allogeneic BMT for treating most inherited diseases is the need to overcome graft rejection with conditioning chemotherapy which is associated with a relatively high morbidity and mortality. This can be eliminated if the transplant is done in utero when the fetus is unable to reject donor hematopoietic stem cells (HSC). We studied the efficacy of T cell-depleted (TCD) parental bone marrow as a source of HSC for transplantation into early gestation non-defective fetal rhesus monkeys. Thirteen opposite sexed TCD transplants were done into 44 day fetal recipients and 12 into 61 day recipients (165 day total gestation). The procedure-related mortality was 8%, all in the earlier age group. The overall survival was 60% at birth with a projected survival of 44 +/- 10% at 1.5 years with no difference between the two age groups. We used a PCR assay for the rhesus Y chromosome to detect male donor cells in female recipients (six animals transplanted at 44 days and five at 63 days). The overall engraftment rate was 73% with no difference as a function of gestational age at transplant. In six long-term surviving engrafted females we detected donor cells in the peripheral blood and bone marrow up to 3 years of age. We found a delay in the appearance of donor cells in the peripheral blood in engrafted animals, in some cases for up to 6 months post-BMT. In vitro mixed lymphocyte reaction and cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity studies between the recipient and donor cells indicate that tolerance was induced to donor cells. Individual and pooled erythroid and myeloid marrow colonies grown in methyl cellulose were collected and analyzed for donor origin by PCR. The amount of donor cells in marrows from long-term engrafted animals was < 0.1%. In a fetal recipient studied at 35 days post-BMT, donor cells were detected in bone marrow and liver in both erythroid and myeloid lineages. These results indicate that TCD parental marrow can durably engraft in utero. While the engraftment rate is similar to that seen with fetal liver as the source of HSC, the degree of peripheral blood engraftment (percent donor cells) in this non-defective primate model is low. It will require increasing the percent pre-or postnatally for this approach to be clinically relevant in those disorders in which there is no selective survival advantage for normal engrafted donor cells.
使用异基因骨髓移植治疗大多数遗传性疾病的一个主要问题是,需要通过预处理化疗来克服移植物排斥反应,而这种化疗会带来相对较高的发病率和死亡率。如果在子宫内进行移植,此时胎儿无法排斥供体造血干细胞(HSC),则可以消除这一问题。我们研究了去除T细胞的(TCD)亲代骨髓作为HSC来源移植到妊娠早期无缺陷的恒河猴胎儿体内的疗效。对44天龄的胎儿受体进行了13例异性TCD移植,对61天龄的受体进行了12例移植(总妊娠期为165天)。与手术相关的死亡率为8%,均发生在年龄较小的组中。出生时的总体存活率为60%,预计1.5岁时的存活率为44±10%,两组之间无差异。我们使用针对恒河猴Y染色体的PCR检测方法,在雌性受体中检测雄性供体细胞(6只动物在44天时移植,5只在63天时移植)。总体植入率为73%,与移植时的胎龄无关。在6只长期存活的植入雌性动物中,我们在其3岁时的外周血和骨髓中检测到了供体细胞。我们发现植入动物外周血中供体细胞的出现有所延迟,在某些情况下,移植后长达6个月。受体和供体细胞之间的体外混合淋巴细胞反应和细胞介导的淋巴细胞毒性研究表明,对供体细胞产生了耐受性。收集在甲基纤维素中生长的单个和汇集的红系和髓系骨髓集落,并通过PCR分析其供体来源。长期植入动物骨髓中的供体细胞数量<0.1%。在一只移植后35天研究的胎儿受体中,在骨髓和肝脏的红系和髓系谱系中均检测到了供体细胞。这些结果表明,TCD亲代骨髓可以在子宫内持久植入。虽然植入率与以胎儿肝脏作为HSC来源时相似,但在这个无缺陷的灵长类动物模型中,外周血植入程度(供体细胞百分比)较低。对于正常植入的供体细胞没有选择性生存优势的那些疾病,要使这种方法具有临床相关性,需要在出生前或出生后提高百分比。