Abelson J L, Nesse R M, Weg J G, Curtis G C
Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, USA.
Psychosom Med. 1996 Jul-Aug;58(4):302-13. doi: 10.1097/00006842-199607000-00002.
The goals of this study were to: a) confirm prior evidence that the respiratory stimulant doxapram induces panic attacks and produces excessive hyperventilation in patients with panic disorder and b) explore the impact of cognitive mediators on symptom and respiratory responses.
Thirty-two subjects (16 patients and 16 controls) received doxapram (0.5 mg/kg) and placebo infusions while symptom, respiratory, and heart rate responses were monitored. Subjects were randomly assigned to receive either a standard introduction or a cognitive intervention designed to reduce the panic responses of panic patients to laboratory challenges.
Doxapram was a potent and specific panicogenic agent, inducing panic in 75% of patients and 12.5% of controls. Compared with controls, patients also showed a greater decrease in end tidal carbon dioxide (CO2) and greater increases in minute ventilation, respiratory frequency, and heart rate. The cognitive intervention substantially attenuated the excessive hyperventilatory response of patients but did not fully normalize their breathing patterns. Tidal volume was the only respiratory measure not significantly altered by the cognitive intervention.
In patients with panic disorder, doxapram (0.5 mg/kg) triggers panic attacks about as potently as 7% CO2 and more potently than 5% CO2 or lactate. Psychological factors can modulate the appearance of ventilatory abnormalities in panic patients, but persistent respiratory disturbances were still seen. Psychological factors and respiratory physiology both appear to be important phenomena in laboratory panic.
本研究的目的是:a)证实先前的证据,即呼吸兴奋剂多沙普仑可诱发惊恐发作,并在惊恐障碍患者中导致过度通气;b)探讨认知调节因素对症状和呼吸反应的影响。
32名受试者(16名患者和16名对照)接受多沙普仑(0.5mg/kg)和安慰剂输注,同时监测症状、呼吸和心率反应。受试者被随机分配接受标准介绍或认知干预,旨在减少惊恐患者对实验室挑战的惊恐反应。
多沙普仑是一种强效且特异性的致惊恐剂,在75%的患者和12.5%的对照中诱发惊恐。与对照相比,患者的呼气末二氧化碳(CO2)下降幅度更大,分钟通气量、呼吸频率和心率增加幅度更大。认知干预显著减弱了患者过度的通气反应,但未使其呼吸模式完全恢复正常。潮气量是唯一未因认知干预而显著改变的呼吸指标。
在惊恐障碍患者中,多沙普仑(0.5mg/kg)诱发惊恐发作的效力与7%二氧化碳相当,比5%二氧化碳或乳酸更有效。心理因素可调节惊恐患者通气异常的表现,但仍可见持续性呼吸紊乱。心理因素和呼吸生理学在实验室诱发的惊恐中似乎都是重要现象。