Leon A C, Olfson M, Weissman M M, Portera L, Fireman B H, Blacklow R S, Hoven C, Broadhead W E
Department of Psychiatry, Cornell University Medical College, New York, NY 10021, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 1996 Jul;11(7):426-30. doi: 10.1007/BF02600191.
We evaluated a set of diagnostic screens for mental disorders in primary care. A self-administered screening questionnaire containing 26 items testing for multiple mental disorders was completed by 1,001 patients. Brief diagnostic modules, structured for psychiatric diagnoses, were subsequently administered to each patient by a research nurse. Operating characteristics of the screens were as follows: alcohol dependence (sensitivity [SE] 0.75; positive predictive value [PPV] 0.58; [kappa] 0.63), drug dependence (SE 0.50; PPV 0.50; kappa 0.50), generalized anxiety disorder (SE 0.74; PPV 0.44; kappa 0.44), major depressive disorder (SE 0.71; PPV 0.52; kappa 0.50), obsessive compulsive disorder (SE 0.71; PPV 0.15; kappa 0.21), and panic disorder (SE 0.71; PPV 0.43; kappa 0.48). Other chance-corrected measures of agreement are also reported, and criterion validity of the screens is examined. The results provide evidence that the screens discriminate between patients with symptomatology meeting established diagnostic criteria and those without. They detected previously unrecognized cases in this study and may prove to be valuable tools for psychiatric diagnosis in primary care.
我们评估了一套用于基层医疗中精神障碍的诊断筛查方法。1001名患者完成了一份包含26个项目的自我管理筛查问卷,该问卷用于检测多种精神障碍。随后,研究护士对每位患者进行了为精神科诊断构建的简短诊断模块。这些筛查方法的操作特征如下:酒精依赖(灵敏度[SE]0.75;阳性预测值[PPV]0.58;卡帕值[kappa]0.63),药物依赖(SE 0.50;PPV 0.50;kappa 0.50),广泛性焦虑障碍(SE 0.74;PPV 0.44;kappa 0.44),重度抑郁症(SE 0.71;PPV 0.52;kappa 0.50),强迫症(SE 0.71;PPV 0.15;kappa 0.21),以及惊恐障碍(SE 0.71;PPV 0.43;kappa 0.48)。还报告了其他一致性的机会校正测量方法,并检验了筛查方法的标准效度。结果提供了证据,表明这些筛查方法能够区分有符合既定诊断标准症状的患者和没有症状的患者。它们在本研究中检测出了先前未被识别的病例,并且可能被证明是基层医疗中精神科诊断的有价值工具。