Alemi F, Stephens R C, Muise K, Dyches H, Mosavel M, Butts J
Health Administration Program, Cleveland State University, Ohio, USA.
Med Care. 1996 Oct;34(10 Suppl):OS21-31. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199610003-00003.
The authors analyzed the impact of home health education by studying the impact of a computer service called Community Health Rap. When patients call this service, the computer records their questions and alerts an expert who records a response. Subsequently, the computer alerts the patient that the question has been addressed.
Subjects included a group of 82 pregnant women who had used cocaine during or 1 month before pregnancy (as reported by the woman) and a group of residents of zip code areas with the lowest income in Cleveland. From the drug-using pregnant women, we collected data regarding satisfaction with Community Health Rap, usage of Community Health Rap per month, self-reported health status (using the General Health Survey), and the extent of drug use (using the Addiction Severity Index). Trained coders also classified the nature of questions posed to the Community Health Rap by either the pregnant women who abuse drugs or the members of target households. Among the pregnant women who abuse drugs, we compared the differences between those who used the service and those who did not. To control for baseline differences between the two groups, analysis of co-variance was used with exit values as the dependent variables, the baseline values as the co-variates, and participation in the Community Health Rap as the independent variable.
Almost half (45%) of poor, undereducated subjects who lived in inner urban areas used the computer service. Content analysis of Community Health Rap messages revealed that subjects had many questions that were of a social nature (regarding sex, relationships, etc), in addition to medical questions. Analysis showed that poor health status, more frequent drug use, lower education, and age did not affect regular use of Community Health Rap service. No health outcomes or utilization of treatment were associated with regular use of Community Health Rap. One exception, however, was that regular users of Community Health Rap reported slower improvement of their pain than those who did not use Community Health Rap.
These data suggest that expansion of information services to households will not leave the poor and the undereducated population groups "behind." They will use computer services, though such services may not have an impact on their health status or cost of care.
作者通过研究一项名为“社区健康说唱”的计算机服务的影响,分析了家庭健康教育的影响。当患者拨打这项服务时,计算机记录他们的问题,并提醒一位专家记录回复。随后,计算机提醒患者问题已得到解答。
研究对象包括一组82名在孕期或怀孕前1个月使用过可卡因的孕妇(据孕妇自述),以及克利夫兰收入最低的邮政编码区域的居民。对于使用毒品的孕妇,我们收集了她们对“社区健康说唱”的满意度、每月使用“社区健康说唱”的频率、自我报告的健康状况(使用一般健康调查)以及毒品使用程度(使用成瘾严重程度指数)的数据。训练有素的编码人员还对滥用药物的孕妇或目标家庭的成员向“社区健康说唱”提出的问题的性质进行了分类。在滥用药物的孕妇中,我们比较了使用该服务的孕妇和未使用该服务的孕妇之间的差异。为了控制两组之间的基线差异,使用协方差分析,将退出值作为因变量,基线值作为协变量,参与“社区健康说唱”作为自变量。
居住在城市中心地区的贫困、受教育程度低的研究对象中,近一半(45%)使用了该计算机服务。对“社区健康说唱”信息的内容分析表明,除了医疗问题外,研究对象还有许多具有社会性质的问题(关于性、人际关系等)。分析表明,健康状况差、更频繁地使用毒品、教育程度低和年龄并不会影响对“社区健康说唱”服务的经常使用。经常使用“社区健康说唱”与健康结果或治疗的使用无关。然而,一个例外是,经常使用“社区健康说唱”的人报告说,他们的疼痛改善速度比不使用“社区健康说唱”的人慢。
这些数据表明,向家庭扩展信息服务不会让贫困和受教育程度低的人群“掉队”。他们会使用计算机服务,尽管此类服务可能对他们的健康状况或护理成本没有影响。