Cornel M, Knibbe R A, Knottnerus J A, Volovics A, Drop M J
Department of General Practice, University of Limburg, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Alcohol Alcohol. 1996 May;31(3):287-96. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.alcalc.a008149.
In The Netherlands general practice attenders are not usually questioned about their drinking habits. The objective of this study was to determine to what extent easily available data (e.g. age, gender) can be used to identify categories of patients who are at risk of problem drinking as a preliminary to more intensive screening. Sixteen practices with a total population of 32,000 patients were involved in the study. All problem drinkers known by their GPs and a random sample of one in ten patients not thought to be problem drinkers were admitted to the study at their first surgery visit during a 1-year period. A screening questionnaire was used to find hidden problem drinkers amongst the individuals thought to be non-problem drinkers. The overall response rate was 91% (n = 1405). Problem drinking was detected in 6% (n = 82) of the group regarded by the GPs as non-problem drinkers (n = 1283). Male gender, smoking, life events and chronic social problems were the strongest non-alcohol-related predictors of hidden problem drinking. We conclude that a pre-selection of patients with a greater risk of problem drinking can be made without information related directly to alcohol. Case-finding in this category is much more effective and probably much more acceptable both to the GP and the patients, than the screening of all patients.
在荷兰,通常不会询问全科医疗就诊者的饮酒习惯。本研究的目的是确定易于获取的数据(如年龄、性别)在多大程度上可用于识别有饮酒问题风险的患者类别,作为更深入筛查的前奏。该研究涉及16家医疗机构,总人口为32000名患者。在1年期间,所有被全科医生知晓的问题饮酒者以及十分之一被认为不是问题饮酒者的患者随机样本,在他们首次就诊时被纳入研究。使用一份筛查问卷在被认为不是问题饮酒者的个体中找出隐藏的问题饮酒者。总体回复率为91%(n = 1405)。在全科医生认为不是问题饮酒者的群体(n = 1283)中,有6%(n = 82)被检测出存在问题饮酒。男性、吸烟、生活事件和慢性社会问题是隐藏问题饮酒最强的非酒精相关预测因素。我们得出结论,在没有直接与酒精相关信息的情况下,可以对有更高饮酒问题风险的患者进行预选。在这一类别中进行病例发现比筛查所有患者更有效,而且可能对全科医生和患者都更易接受。