Nicolini F A, Lee P, Malycky J L, Lefkovits J, Kottke-Marchant K, Plow E F, Topol E J
Department of Cardiology, Joseph J. Jacobs Center for Thrombosis and Vascular Biology, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
Blood Coagul Fibrinolysis. 1996 Jan;7(1):39-48. doi: 10.1097/00001721-199601000-00005.
The success of current thrombolytic strategies is undermined by ongoing thrombin activity, but it is uncertain whether prevention of thrombin generation or direct thrombin antagonism is effective in achieving more optimal thrombolysis. To address this question, 24 dogs with electrically induced coronary thrombus undergoing thrombolysis with tissue-type plasminogen activator (1 mg/kg) over 20 min, were given one of the following adjunctive regimens in a random fashion. Twelve dogs received saline, and served as the control group; a direct thrombin antagonist, hirudin, was given at a dose of 20 micrograms/kg/min for 90 min to six dogs, and a selective factor Xa inhibitor, tick anticoagulant peptide (TAP), was administered to six dogs at a dose of 30 micrograms/kg/min for 90 min. The time to reperfusion was similar in the saline and hirudin groups (34 +/- 4 vs 37 +/- 7 min; P = NS) but shorter in the TAP group (21 +/- 4 min; P < 0.05). Coronary blood flow was restored to 100% of its baseline value for 7 +/- 2 min in control dogs, and for 20 +/- 6 min in the hirudin group (P < 0.05). In the TAP group, coronary blood flow was restored to 100% of its baseline value for more than 120 min in all dogs (P < 0.01 vs others treatments). Reocclusion occurred in 89% and 50% of dogs receiving saline and hirudin, respectively (P = NS), but in none of the TAP-treated dogs (P < 0.01). Plasma fibrinopeptide A (FpA) and thrombin-antithrombin III complex (TAT) levels were determined in all dogs as indicators of thrombin activation. In the saline group, FpA and TAT during reperfusion were 19 +/- 2 ng/ml and 104 +/- 24 ng/ml respectively (P < 0.02 vs baseline) indicating high thrombin activity. In contrast, during reperfusion in hirudin-treated dogs FpA and TAT remained similar to baseline (10 +/- 3 ng/ml and 53 +/- 4 ng/ml respectively; both P < 0.05 vs saline). Reperfusion in TAP-treated dogs did not alter FpA and TAT in plasma, which remained similar to baseline (9 +/- 1 ng/ml and 39 +/- 5 ng/ml respectively; both P < 0.05 vs saline). Scanning electron microscopy of coronary arteries showed residual thrombi with intense platelet and fibrin deposition adherent to the deendothelialized surface of the vessels following saline and hirudin therapy. In contrast, TAP-treated arteries were characterized by the absence of fibrin and minimal platelet deposition. In conclusion, these hemodynamic, biochemical and morphologic data suggest that adjunctive treatment with a higher tier blockade of the coagulation cascade is superior to direct thrombin inhibition in maintaining coronary artery patency following thrombolysis in the experimental canine electrolytic model. These findings highlight the potential adverse effects of unchecked thrombin generation in the setting of thrombolytic therapy.
当前溶栓策略的成功受到持续凝血酶活性的影响,但凝血酶生成的预防或直接凝血酶拮抗在实现更优化的溶栓方面是否有效尚不确定。为解决这个问题,24只患有电诱导冠状动脉血栓的犬接受组织型纤溶酶原激活剂(1mg/kg)20分钟的溶栓治疗,并随机给予以下辅助治疗方案之一。12只犬接受生理盐水,作为对照组;6只犬给予剂量为20微克/千克/分钟的直接凝血酶拮抗剂水蛭素,持续90分钟;6只犬给予剂量为30微克/千克/分钟的选择性因子Xa抑制剂蜱抗凝肽(TAP),持续90分钟。生理盐水组和水蛭素组的再灌注时间相似(34±4分钟对37±7分钟;P=无显著性差异),但TAP组较短(21±4分钟;P<0.05)。对照组犬的冠状动脉血流恢复到基线值的100%持续7±2分钟,水蛭素组为20±6分钟(P<0.05)。在TAP组,所有犬的冠状动脉血流恢复到基线值的100%超过120分钟(与其他治疗相比P<0.01)。接受生理盐水和水蛭素治疗的犬分别有89%和50%发生再闭塞(P=无显著性差异),但TAP治疗的犬无一发生再闭塞(P<0.01)。测定所有犬的血浆纤维蛋白肽A(FpA)和凝血酶 - 抗凝血酶III复合物(TAT)水平作为凝血酶激活的指标。生理盐水组再灌注期间FpA和TAT分别为19±2纳克/毫升和104±24纳克/毫升(与基线相比P<0.02),表明凝血酶活性高。相比之下,水蛭素治疗的犬再灌注期间FpA和TAT与基线相似(分别为10±3纳克/毫升和53±4纳克/毫升;与生理盐水组相比均P<0.05)。TAP治疗的犬再灌注时血浆FpA和TAT未改变,与基线相似(分别为9±1纳克/毫升和39±5纳克/毫升;与生理盐水组相比均P<0.05)。冠状动脉的扫描电子显微镜检查显示,生理盐水和水蛭素治疗后,血管去内皮化表面有残留血栓,伴有强烈的血小板和纤维蛋白沉积。相比之下,TAP治疗的动脉的特点是无纤维蛋白且血小板沉积极少。总之,这些血流动力学、生化和形态学数据表明,在实验性犬电解模型中,溶栓后在维持冠状动脉通畅方面,凝血级联更高层次阻断的辅助治疗优于直接凝血酶抑制。这些发现突出了溶栓治疗中不受控制的凝血酶生成的潜在不良反应。