Purghé F
Dipartimento di Psicologia, Università di Torino, Italy.
Perception. 1995;24(8):905-18. doi: 10.1068/p240905.
It has been claimed that an illusory figure is prevented from occurring when there is contrary evidence to occlusion, eg when the inducers are pictorial representations of 'complete' three-dimensional (3-D) objects. However, it was recently shown that illusory figures may also be induced by such pictorially 3-D inducers. Here, further evidence on this point is presented. Two experiments were carried out. The first was aimed at showing that an illusory figure can be induced even by stereoscopically 3-D 'complete' inducers; the second was aimed at checking whether inducers that are stereoscopically seen as closer than the induced figure can contribute to strengthen the illusion. The results show that stereoscopically 3-D inducing patterns can affect the illusion both in the absence of any occlusion cue and when there is contrary evidence to occlusion. These conclusions seriously challenge all the interpretations that regard occlusion, or interposition, cues as necessary for the formation of illusory figures.
有人声称,当存在与遮挡相反的证据时,比如当诱导物是“完整”三维(3-D)物体的图形表示时,虚幻图形就不会出现。然而,最近有研究表明,这种具有三维图形特征的诱导物也可能诱发虚幻图形。在此,给出关于这一点的进一步证据。进行了两项实验。第一个实验旨在表明,即使是通过立体三维“完整”诱导物也能诱发虚幻图形;第二个实验旨在检验,在立体视觉上被视为比诱发图形更近的诱导物是否有助于增强这种错觉。结果表明,立体三维诱导图案在没有任何遮挡线索时以及存在与遮挡相反的证据时,都能影响错觉。这些结论严重挑战了所有认为遮挡或插入线索是虚幻图形形成所必需的解释。