Fouquet R, Gage H
Department of Economics, University of Surrey, Guildford, United Kingdom.
J Med Screen. 1996;3(2):90-6. doi: 10.1177/096914139600300210.
To estimate the effect of screening on invasive cervical cancer registrations in England.
The Health of the Nation target for cervical cancer seeks to reduce the incidence of invasive cases (ICD 180) by at least 20% between 1986 and 2000.
The available area-level statistics on invasive cervical cancer registrations, screening activity, and socioeconomic and behavioural characteristics for 145 district health authorities in England over the period 1985-91 were collected. A multiple regression analysis sought to explain variations in incidence rates by relating screening and socioeconomic and behavioural variables to registration rates.
Districts with higher unemployment levels and higher numbers of pregnancies in young women had higher registration rates for invasive cervical cancer. The cervical smear rate for women aged 35-64 in a district was positively related to registrations, whereas the relation was negative for the 20-34 age group.
The higher registration rates for invasive cervical cancer in districts with higher cervical smear rates for women aged 35-64 may reflect historically lower screening cover. The negative relation between the cervical smear rate and invasive cervical cancer registrations in women aged 20-34 is accompanied by high registration rates for preinvasive (CIN III) cervical cancer (ICD 233.1). For the advantages of the Pap test to be fully realised, and for invasive cervical cancer registrations to fall in line with the Health of the Nation targets, a comprehensive screening programme, with a high take up rate is required. The various changes to the screening programme introduced since 1988 should help to achieve this. Public health policy should focus on educating the population about the risk factors for cervical cancer and the significance of screening.
评估筛查对英格兰浸润性宫颈癌登记率的影响。
《国民健康计划》中宫颈癌目标旨在到2000年将浸润性病例(国际疾病分类第180号)的发病率在1986年基础上至少降低20%。
收集了1985 - 1991年期间英格兰145个地区卫生当局关于浸润性宫颈癌登记、筛查活动以及社会经济和行为特征的可用地区层面统计数据。采用多元回归分析,通过将筛查、社会经济和行为变量与登记率相关联来解释发病率的差异。
失业率较高以及年轻女性怀孕人数较多的地区,浸润性宫颈癌登记率较高。一个地区35 - 64岁女性的宫颈涂片率与登记率呈正相关,而在20 - 34岁年龄组中这种关系为负相关。
35 - 64岁女性宫颈涂片率较高的地区浸润性宫颈癌登记率较高,可能反映了历史上较低的筛查覆盖率。20 - 34岁女性宫颈涂片率与浸润性宫颈癌登记率之间的负相关,伴随着宫颈原位癌(CIN III)(国际疾病分类第233.1号)的高登记率。为了充分实现巴氏试验的益处,并使浸润性宫颈癌登记率符合《国民健康计划》目标,需要一个全面的、高参与率的筛查计划。自1988年以来对筛查计划进行的各种改变应有助于实现这一目标。公共卫生政策应注重对民众进行宫颈癌危险因素及筛查重要性的教育。