Schifrin L G, Tayan J R
Int J Health Serv. 1977;7(3):359-81. doi: 10.2190/PC15-WPVK-5K1W-JCP4.
This articel reviews the literature pertinent to the "drug lag" issue, in order to evaluate the evidence underlying the thesis that the U.S. has suffered from a slow-down in the rate and timing of new drug introductions, to the detriment of patients, because of the stricter requirements since 1962 regarding proof of safety and efficacy for new drugs. Comparing the post-1962 record in the U.S. with (a) the U.S. record before 1962 and (b) the post-1962 record in other, mainly Western European, countries, the weight of evidence and argument falls on the side of those who see a lag existing in the U.S. Other evidence, more subjective, supports the view that this lag imposes net positive costs on U.S. patients. However, it is not clear that the 1962 Drug Act is the sole, or even the main, cause of the lag. Instead, the drug information system and its inefficiencies emerge as the fundamental reason for the existence of a lag; hence, changes in the administration of the law by the Food and Drug Administration and greater efficiency by companies in supporting New Drug Applications can help close the gap, but probably only in minor degree. The solution to the lag problem lies in formulating and implementing a drug information system that quickly and accurately gathers, interprets, and disseminates information on the positive and negative effects of newly introduced drugs; with such a system, protection of drug users from undue risk is compatible with a greater rate and more rapid appearance of new drug discoveries.
本文回顾了与“药品滞后”问题相关的文献,以便评估这样一种论点的依据:自1962年以来,由于对新药安全性和有效性证明的要求更为严格,美国新药推出的速度和时间有所放缓,对患者造成了损害。将美国1962年后的记录与(a)1962年前的美国记录以及(b)其他主要是西欧国家1962年后的记录进行比较,证据和论据的权重倾向于认为美国存在滞后的一方。其他更为主观的证据支持了这样一种观点,即这种滞后给美国患者带来了净正成本。然而,尚不清楚1962年的《药品法案》是滞后的唯一原因,甚至也不是主要原因。相反,药品信息系统及其低效率才是滞后存在的根本原因;因此,美国食品药品监督管理局法律管理方式的改变以及公司在支持新药申请方面更高的效率有助于缩小差距,但可能程度有限。滞后问题的解决办法在于制定并实施一个药品信息系统,该系统能够快速、准确地收集、解读和传播有关新推出药品正负效应的信息;有了这样一个系统,保护药品使用者免受不当风险与更快的新药发现速度和更多新药的出现是相容的。