Rushton V E, Horner K, Worthington H V
Tumer Dental School, University of Manchester, England.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 1996 Aug;24(4):272-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.1996.tb00858.x.
The aim of this study was to determine the influence of a range of patient and dentist factors on the prescription of bitewing radiography. A postal questionnaire of general dental practitioners working in the Birmingham and Manchester areas of England was used. Dentists were requested to score the influence of 15 factors upon their decision whether or not to take bitewing radiographs. Some of these factors were chosen to represent accepted "high caries risk" factors, some "low risk" factors, while others were chosen as they should be irrelevant to prescription of bitewing radiographs. There was a questionnaire response of 70.8%. Dentists recognized accepted high caries risk factors as being an indicator for bitewing radiography but the influence of low caries risk factors was less clear. Only "good oral hygiene" and the presence of "few restorations" were perceived as relevant to bitewing prescription, while fissure sealants were seen as an influence in favour of radiography by almost one third of dentists. Dentists tended to be influenced in their radiographic practice by the opinions of patients and fears of medico-legal consequences. Pregnancy was seen as contra-indicatory for bitewings by almost all dentists. These results suggest that greater emphasis should be placed upon radiographic selection criteria in dental education.
本研究的目的是确定一系列患者和牙医因素对咬合翼片X线摄影处方的影响。采用了对在英格兰伯明翰和曼彻斯特地区工作的普通牙科医生进行邮寄问卷调查的方式。要求牙医对15个因素对其决定是否拍摄咬合翼片X线照片的影响进行评分。其中一些因素被选为代表公认的“高龋风险”因素,一些为“低风险”因素,而其他一些因素被选中是因为它们应该与咬合翼片X线摄影处方无关。问卷调查的回复率为70.8%。牙医认可公认的高龋风险因素是咬合翼片X线摄影的一个指标,但低龋风险因素的影响则不太明确。只有“良好的口腔卫生”和“较少的修复体”被认为与咬合翼片处方相关,而几乎三分之一的牙医认为窝沟封闭剂是有利于进行X线摄影的一个影响因素。牙医在其X线摄影实践中往往受到患者意见和对医疗法律后果的担忧的影响。几乎所有牙医都认为怀孕是咬合翼片X线摄影的禁忌证。这些结果表明,在牙科教育中应更加重视X线摄影的选择标准。