Gutteridge D H, Retallack R W, Ward L C, Stuckey B G, Stewart G O, Prince R L, Kent G N, Bhagat C I, Price R I, Thompson R I, Nicholson G C
Department of Endocrinology, Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, Nedlands, Australia.
Bone. 1996 Oct;19(4):387-94. doi: 10.1016/s8756-3282(96)00224-4.
An intravenous dosage schedule using pamidronate disodium, based on biochemical severity, was used to treat 71 patients with Paget's disease who had no previous bisphosphonate treatment. Disease severity was stratified by fasting hydroxyproline excretion (HypE): Group (Gp) I (mild disease; HypE < 5.0 mumol/LGF) received a total dose of 120 mg; Gp II (moderate; HypE 5.00-9.99) received 180 mg; and Gp III (severe; HypE > or = 10) received 240 mg. Within each group patients were randomly allocated to receive daily 30 mg or 60 mg infusions. Observations for 2 years included pain scores, indices of bone turnover, and radiology of lytic lesions. There was no difference in biochemical responses, or in the percentage of patients with early fever, between the 30 mg and 60 mg daily subgroups; for convenience, 60 mg infusions are recommended. Neutrophils and total white cell counts were both significantly below baseline 4 days after the first infusion; lymphocytes were significantly reduced by day 2; and all three measures had returned to within the reference range by day 6. Remission was assessed at 6 months, when both plasma alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and HypE had reached stable nadirs. Increasing severity was associated with increasing resistance to suppression of HypE at 6 months to within the reference range: Gp I, 87%; Gp II, 44%; and Gp III, 0% (p < 0.0001 by chi-square test). Biochemical relapse at 2 years (defined as ALP 50% above the 6 month level) was also dependent on initial disease severity (Gp I, 6%; GpII, 39%; Gp III, 62%; p < 0.0005 by chi-square test). There was no association between time to relapse and either initial dose or log dose. Radiologic lytic lesions (in 22 patients) were all in remission at 3 months; however, relapse rates at 2 years appeared to be severity-dependent: Gp I, 13%; Gp II, 43%; and Gp III, 57% (n.s. by chi-square test). Remission rates based on a fall to < 50% of pretreatment of either HypE or ALP were more in accord with lytic lesion remission rates than were rates based on HypE falling to within the reference range. Pamidronate produced a significant reduction from baseline in Pagetic bone, Pagetic joint, and unrelated musculoskeletal pain in the first 6 months (p < 0.0001). From 0 months to 2 years the maintenance of improvement in bone pain (p < 0.005) and joint pain (p < 0.05) was significantly better than in unrelated pain. Pamidronate is a safe, welltolerated, and effective treatment for Paget's disease. In spite of larger dosage in severe disease, increasing severity was associated with resistance to normalization of biochemistry and a higher incidence of biochemical and radiological relapse at 2 years. Our current dosage recommendation would be for two 60 mg infusions for mild disease (Gp I); and four 60 mg infusions for moderate disease (Gp II). Severe disease (Gp III) remains a challenge; regardless of dosage, the majority of patients will be in relapse 2 years after a single course of treatment.
一项基于生化严重程度的帕米膦酸二钠静脉给药方案,用于治疗71例先前未接受过双膦酸盐治疗的佩吉特病患者。疾病严重程度通过空腹羟脯氨酸排泄量(HypE)进行分层:I组(轻度疾病;HypE<5.0 μmol/LGF)接受的总剂量为120 mg;II组(中度;HypE 5.00 - 9.99)接受180 mg;III组(重度;HypE≥10)接受240 mg。在每组患者中,随机分配接受每日30 mg或60 mg的输注。为期2年的观察指标包括疼痛评分、骨转换指标以及溶骨性病变的放射学检查。每日30 mg和60 mg亚组之间在生化反应或早期发热患者百分比方面没有差异;为方便起见,推荐60 mg输注。首次输注后4天,中性粒细胞和白细胞总数均显著低于基线水平;淋巴细胞在第2天显著减少;到第6天,所有这三项指标均恢复到参考范围内。在6个月时评估缓解情况,此时血浆碱性磷酸酶(ALP)和HypE均达到稳定的最低点。疾病严重程度增加与6个月时HypE抑制到参考范围内的耐药性增加相关:I组,87%;II组,44%;III组,0%(经卡方检验,p<0.0001)。2年时的生化复发(定义为ALP高于6个月水平的50%)也取决于初始疾病严重程度(I组,6%;II组,39%;III组,62%;经卡方检验,p<0.0005)。复发时间与初始剂量或对数剂量之间均无关联。放射学溶骨性病变(22例患者)在3个月时均缓解;然而,2年时的复发率似乎取决于严重程度:I组,13%;II组,43%;III组,57%(经卡方检验,无显著性差异)。基于HypE或ALP降至治疗前水平的<50%的缓解率比基于HypE降至参考范围内的缓解率更符合溶骨性病变的缓解率。帕米膦酸在最初6个月使佩吉特骨、佩吉特关节及无关肌肉骨骼疼痛较基线水平显著降低(p<0.0001)。从0个月到2年,骨痛(p<0.