Huang P, Taghian A, Allam A, Freeman J, Duffy M, Suit H
Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA.
Radiat Res. 1996 Mar;145(3):337-42.
This study has evaluated the impact of the suppression and recovery of the residual immunity in NCr/Sed nude (nu/nu) mice after whole-body irradiation using xenotransplantability and tumor control probability as the end points. For this investigation the xenograft was a human soft tissue sarcoma (HSTS26T). Two assays, the TD50 (the number of tumor cells required to induce a tumor in 50% of the recipients) and the TCD50 (the radiation dose required to control 50% of tumors) were used. For TD50 assays, tumor cells were injected subcutaneously (sc) into the legs of control and whole-body- irradiated nude mice at 1 day or 4, 8 or 12 weeks after irradiation. For TCD50 assays, tumors were transplanted sc into the legs of nude mice which had not been irradiated or which had been given whole-body irradiation at 1 day or 12 weeks prior to transplantation. The tumors were given single-dose irradiation when they reached 6 mm mean diameter under clamp-hypoxic conditions. The results show that the TD50's of mice receiving the injection 1 day and 4 and 8 weeks after whole-body irradiation were 3.6 to >100 times lower than that of unirradiated mice. Two groups which showed a statistically significant difference in TD50 's were those which received the injection 1 day and 8 weeks after whole-body irradiation (P < 0.01 and P < 0.05, respectively). No difference was found in TD50 values between mice that received injection 12 weeks after whole-body irradiation and those which were not irradiated. The TCD50 values of tumors in nonirradiated mice and in mice which had received whole-body irradiation 1 day and 12 weeks prior to to transplantation were 26.8, 44.1 and 33.9 Gy, respectively. Significantly lower TCD50 values were found in groups of nonirradiated mice or mice which received whole-body irradiation 12 weeks prior to transplantation in comparison with the group of mice that received whole-body irradiation on day 1 (both P < 0.05). No significant difference was found between the TCD50 values of the group of mice that received whole-body irradiation 12 weeks prior to transplantation and those for nonirradiated controls. Our conclusion is that the whole-body irradiation can enhance the transplantability of the HSTS26T tumor in nude mice significantly; this enhancing effect will decrease to the pre-irradiation level by 12 weeks after whole-body irradiation. Also, the suppression and recovery of residual immunity after whole-body irradiation can influence the TCD50 values of the same tumor xenografts in nude mice significantly. The changes in TD50 and TCD50 values correlate with the depletion and recovery of the total splenic lymphoid cell number, and especially in natural killer cell activity. We recommend that further immunosuppression in nude mice is necessary when using this model system for studies of human tumors.
本研究以异种移植能力和肿瘤控制概率为终点,评估了全身照射后NCr/Sed裸(nu/nu)小鼠残余免疫力的抑制和恢复情况。本次研究采用的异种移植瘤是一种人类软组织肉瘤(HSTS26T)。使用了两种测定方法,即TD50(使50%的受体诱发肿瘤所需的肿瘤细胞数量)和TCD50(控制50%肿瘤所需的辐射剂量)。对于TD50测定,在照射后1天或4、8或12周,将肿瘤细胞皮下注射到对照裸鼠和全身照射裸鼠的腿部。对于TCD50测定,将肿瘤移植到未照射或在移植前1天或12周接受过全身照射的裸鼠腿部。当肿瘤在夹闭缺氧条件下平均直径达到6 mm时给予单剂量照射。结果显示,全身照射后1天、4周和8周接受注射的小鼠的TD50比未照射小鼠低3.6至>100倍。TD50有统计学显著差异的两组是全身照射后1天和8周接受注射的组(分别为P < 0.01和P < 0.05)。全身照射后12周接受注射的小鼠与未照射小鼠的TD50值无差异。未照射小鼠以及在移植前1天和12周接受过全身照射的小鼠体内肿瘤的TCD50值分别为26.8、44.1和33.9 Gy。与在第1天接受全身照射的小鼠组相比,未照射小鼠组或在移植前12周接受全身照射的小鼠组的TCD50值显著更低(均为P < 0.05)。在移植前12周接受全身照射的小鼠组与未照射对照组的TCD50值之间未发现显著差异。我们的结论是,全身照射可显著增强HSTS26T肿瘤在裸鼠中的移植能力;这种增强作用在全身照射后12周会降至照射前水平。此外,全身照射后残余免疫力的抑制和恢复可显著影响同一肿瘤异种移植在裸鼠中的TCD50值。TD50和TCD50值的变化与脾淋巴细胞总数的减少和恢复相关,尤其是与自然杀伤细胞活性相关。我们建议,在使用该模型系统研究人类肿瘤时,对裸鼠进行进一步免疫抑制是必要的。