Tayman J, Swanson D A
San Diego Association of Governments, CA 92101, USA.
Demography. 1996 Nov;33(4):523-8.
Many customers demand population forecasts, particularly for small areas. Although the forecast evaluation literature is extensive, it is dominated by a focus on accuracy. We go beyond accuracy by examining the concept of forecast utility in an evaluation of a sample of 2,709 counties and census tracts. We find that forecasters provide "value-added" knowledge for areas experiencing rapid change or areas with relatively large populations. For other areas, reduced value is more common than added value. Our results suggest that new forecasting strategies and methods such as composite modeling may substantially improve forecast utility.
许多客户需要人口预测,尤其是针对小区域的预测。尽管预测评估文献数量众多,但主要集中在准确性方面。我们通过在对2709个县和人口普查区的样本评估中考察预测效用的概念,超越了准确性的范畴。我们发现,对于经历快速变化的地区或人口相对较多的地区,预测者能提供“增值”知识。而对于其他地区,价值降低比价值增加更为常见。我们的结果表明,诸如综合建模等新的预测策略和方法可能会大幅提高预测效用。