Nishida H, Shinbo Y, Kuramitsu M, Motomura H
Kuramitsu Clinic, Health Institution for the Old Harukaze.
Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 1996;98(8):533-54.
In recent years, misidentification syndromes have attracted much attention, and various types of these syndromes have been recognized. However, misidentification syndromes tend to be discussed as case reports or as a whole, and yet there is no established classification. This is primarily due to a small number of cases encountered by each researcher. We propose a new classification of misidentification syndrome based on more than 70 patients with these syndromes, who have been treated at one psychiatric hospital during 20 years. First, delusional misidentification syndromes were classified into two types: misidentification of human relationships represented by descent delusion (relational misidentification), and misidentification of identity itself represented by Capgras symptom and Fregoli symptom (identical misidentification). Next, identical misidentification was subclassified into 3 types: division of identity (divided type), union of identity (unionized type), and transformation of identity (transformed type). Various misidentification syndromes and associated signs and symptoms were evaluated in detail from the aspect of descriptive psychiatry and were compared with our new classification. In addition, this typological study on misidentification was analyzed based on the regressive theory and Jacksonism, and we proposed a hypothesis that there is correspondence between misidentification syndromes and the development of person identification in infants.
近年来,错认综合征备受关注,且已识别出多种此类综合征。然而,错认综合征往往作为病例报告或整体进行讨论,尚无既定分类。这主要是因为每位研究者遇到的病例数量较少。我们基于20年间在一家精神病医院接受治疗的70余例此类综合征患者,提出了一种新的错认综合征分类方法。首先,妄想性错认综合征分为两类:以血统妄想为代表的人际关系错认(关系性错认),以及以卡普格拉症状和弗雷戈里症状为代表的身份本身错认(同一性错认)。其次,同一性错认又细分为3种类型:身份分裂(分裂型)、身份合并(合并型)和身份转变(转变型)。从描述性精神病学角度详细评估了各种错认综合征及相关体征和症状,并与我们的新分类进行了比较。此外,基于退行理论和杰克逊学说对错认的这种类型学研究进行了分析,我们提出了一个假说,即错认综合征与婴儿期个体识别发展之间存在对应关系。