In vitro differentiation potential of the periosteal cells from a membrane bone, the quadratojugal of the embryonic chick.

The quadratojugal (QJ) is a neural crest-derived membrane bone in the maxillary region of the avian head. In vivo its periosteum undergoes both osteogenesis to form membrane bone and chondrogenesis to form secondary cartilage. This bipotential property, which also exists in some other membrane bones, is poorly understood. The present study used cell culture to investigate the differentiation potential of QJ periosteal cells. Three cell populations were enzymatically released from QJ periostea and plated at different densities. Cell density greatly affected phenotypic expression and differentiation pathways. We found two culture conditions that favored osteogenesis and chondrogenesis, respectively. In micromass culture, the periosteal cells produced a layer of osteogenic cells that expressed alkaline phosphatase (APase) and secreted bony extracellular matrix (ECM). In contrast, low-density monolayer culture elicited chondrogenesis. Cells with pericellular refractile ECM and round shape appeared at 7 to 8 days and formed colonies later. The chondrogenic phenotype of these cells was confirmed by immunolocalization of type II collagen and Alcian blue staining of ECM. This result demonstrated that a fully expressed chondrogenic phenotype can be achieved from membrane bone periosteal cells in primary monolayer culture. Chondrogenesis requires a cell density lower than confluence and cannot be initiated in confluent cultures. Among the three cell populations, those cells from the outer layer have the highest growth rate and require the lowest initial plating density (below 5 x 10(3) cells/ml) to achieve chondrogenesis. Cells from the inner layer have the slowest growth rate and chondrify at the highest initial density (below 5 x 10(4) cells/ml). Chondrocytes from all populations express distinct phenotypic markers-APase and type I collagen-from initial chondrogenesis, but are not hypertrophic morphologically. Furthermore, the fact that chondrocytes arise within the same colony as APase-positive polygonal cells suggests that chondrocytes may differentiate from precursors related to the osteogenic cell lineage. This cell culture approach mimics secondary cartilage and membrane bone formation in vivo.