Schaller G, Harding T
Institut universitaire de médecine légale, Genève.
Soz Praventivmed. 1996;41(5):288-94. doi: 10.1007/BF01300434.
An illustrated full colour brochure has been elaborated for Swiss prisoners. This brochure, named "Hygiene and Health in detention", concerns transmissible diseases in general and AIDS in particular. It is meant to replace typed A4 sheets which were not generally read. The evaluation of the brochure took place in a Swiss prison on the basis of 22 questions put to inmates during interviews. Answers of inmates having received the old sheet were compared with answers of inmates who received the new brochure. The evaluation concerning the informations' presentation is positive. The brochure is more attractive than the A4 sheet thanks to its illustrated and coloured presentation (chi-square = 6.52, p = 0.01). Prisoners remember having received the brochure more than the old sheet (chi-square = 10.02, p = 0.001). More prisoners have read the folder than the A4 sheet (chi-square = 4.22, p = 0.04). The evaluation concerning the principal preventive messages is only partially positive. Inmates do not appear to have assimilated the medical information any better than from the old A4 sheet.
已为瑞士囚犯制作了一本配有插图的全彩手册。这本名为《拘留期间的卫生与健康》的手册,总体涉及传染病,尤其关注艾滋病。它旨在取代通常无人阅读的打印A4纸张。手册的评估是在一所瑞士监狱中进行的,通过在访谈中向囚犯提出22个问题来展开。将收到旧纸张的囚犯的回答与收到新手册的囚犯的回答进行了比较。关于信息呈现的评估是积极的。由于其配有插图和彩色的呈现方式,该手册比A4纸张更具吸引力(卡方值 = 6.52,p = 0.01)。囚犯对收到手册的记忆比收到旧纸张的记忆更深刻(卡方值 = 10.02,p = 0.001)。阅读该手册的囚犯比阅读A4纸张的囚犯更多(卡方值 = 4.22,p = 0.04)。关于主要预防信息的评估仅部分积极。囚犯似乎并未比从旧A4纸张中更好地吸收医学信息。