Lee S W, Chen M Z, Chan H W, Lam L, Guo J X, Mao J M, Lam K K, Guo L J, Li H Y, Chan K K
Department of Medicine, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong, China.
Am Heart J. 1996 Dec;132(6):1135-46. doi: 10.1016/s0002-8703(96)90456-1.
Intracoronary stenting has been shown to have better immediate and long-term clinical outcomes and less restenosis than standard balloon angioplasty. However, the benefit was achieved at the cost of higher rates of coronary thrombosis, bleeding complications, the need for anticoagulation, and longer hospital stay. For the latter reasons there is a tendency to replace the anticoagulants by antiplatelet agents alone after stenting. However, we prospectively monitored 150 consecutive patients (133 men, 17 women, mean age 58.5 years) from two centers since February 1993. They all had coronary artery disease and underwent percutaneous implantation of non-heparin-coated Palmaz-Schatz coronary stents under a full but lower dose of anticoagulation. The femoral approach was used in all patients except one. In the 150 patients, 200 stents were implanted in 165 target arteries with 172 lesions. Stenting was performed without the guidance of intravascular ultrasonography; high-pressure poststenting inflation was used in only 17.3% of patients with less than optimal angiographic results. Coronary angiography was performed at baseline, immediately after the procedure, and after 6 months (mean 207 +/- 53.6 days SD) of stenting. The mean (+/-SD) coronary minimum luminal diameter increased from 0.52 0.31 mm to 3.13 +/- 0.42 mm immediately after stenting was performed and was 2.12 +/- 0.91 mm at 6 months. There was a 0% subacute thrombosis rate and a 0% femoral bleeding complication rate in the whole series. Only three (2%) major events occurred: one Q-wave myocardial infarction from closure of an angioplasty site distal to the stent on a very long lesion, one cerebrovascular accident, and one noncoronary-related death. The only patient who underwent the brachial approach had hematoma; otherwise no other minor event occurred. The mean hospital stay was 4.5 days in one of the two study centers. The long-term clinical follow-up rate was 97.3%. The mean (+/- SD) clinical follow-up period was 589 +/- 363 days. Clinical symptoms improved; the percentage of patients who had angina according to the Canadian Cardiovascular Society functional class II, III, and IV was 31.3%, 44.7%, and 4%, respectively, before stenting was performed and was reduced to 4.7%, 3.7%, and 0%, respectively at 6-month follow-up after stenting was performed. The 6-month angiographic restudy rate was 90.6%, and the restenosis rate was 18.3%. In contrast to other reported series, these results support the idea that with careful puncture technique and meticulous postoperative wound care, intracoronary stenting can be successfully performed with the patient under full anticoagulation without major risks of bleeding and femoral vascular complications. Furthermore with a full but comparatively lower dose of anticoagulation, subacute thrombotic complications can be reduced to 0% even with non-heparin-coated stents without the use of intravascular ultrasound guidance and without the use of adjunctive high-pressure poststenting inflation in most patients. The restenosis rate and long-term clinical outcomes remained very favorable.
与标准球囊血管成形术相比,冠状动脉内支架置入术已显示出更好的即刻和长期临床疗效,且再狭窄率更低。然而,这一益处是以较高的冠状动脉血栓形成率、出血并发症、抗凝需求以及更长的住院时间为代价的。由于后述原因,在支架置入术后有仅用抗血小板药物替代抗凝剂的趋势。然而,自1993年2月起,我们前瞻性地监测了来自两个中心的150例连续患者(133例男性,17例女性,平均年龄58.5岁)。他们均患有冠状动脉疾病,并在充分但较低剂量的抗凝治疗下接受了非肝素涂层的帕尔马兹 - 施查茨冠状动脉支架的经皮植入。除1例患者外,所有患者均采用股动脉入路。在这150例患者中,在165条靶血管的172处病变中植入了200枚支架。支架置入术在没有血管内超声引导的情况下进行;对于血管造影结果欠佳的患者,仅17.3%使用了高压后扩张。在基线、术后即刻以及支架置入术后6个月(平均207±53.6天标准差)进行冠状动脉造影。支架置入术后即刻,冠状动脉平均(±标准差)最小管腔直径从0.52±0.31毫米增加到3.13±0.42毫米,6个月时为2.12±0.91毫米。整个系列中,亚急性血栓形成率为0%,股动脉出血并发症率为0%。仅发生了3例(2%)主要事件:1例因支架远端血管成形术部位在很长病变处闭塞导致的Q波心肌梗死,1例脑血管意外,以及1例与非冠状动脉相关的死亡。唯一采用肱动脉入路的患者出现了血肿;除此之外未发生其他轻微事件。两个研究中心之一的平均住院时间为4.5天。长期临床随访率为97.3%。平均(±标准差)临床随访期为589±363天。临床症状改善;在支架置入术前,根据加拿大心血管学会功能分级II级、III级和IV级有心绞痛的患者百分比分别为31.3%、44.7%和4%,在支架置入术后6个月随访时分别降至4.7%、3.7%和0%。6个月时的血管造影复查率为90.6%,再狭窄率为18.3%。与其他报道的系列不同,这些结果支持这样一种观点,即通过仔细的穿刺技术和精心的术后伤口护理,在患者充分抗凝的情况下可以成功进行冠状动脉内支架置入术,而不会有大出血和股血管并发症的重大风险。此外,在充分但相对较低剂量的抗凝治疗下,即使使用非肝素涂层支架,在大多数患者中不使用血管内超声引导且不使用辅助性高压后扩张,亚急性血栓形成并发症也可降至0%。再狭窄率和长期临床疗效仍然非常良好。