Cova M, Frezza F, Shariat-Razavi I, Ukmar M, Mucelli R S, Dalla Palma L
Istituto di Radiologia, Università di Trieste.
Radiol Med. 1996 Sep;92(3):171-9.
To study the MR appearance of knee joint hyaline cartilage, 120 subjects were examined with MRI of the knee. Axial SE proton-density (PD) and T2, GE T1 and GE-MTC sequences were used, as well as coronal SE T1 and sagittal SE PD and T2 sequences. At the patellar and femorotibial cartilages the following variables were investigated: thickness, surface, signal intensity and visibility. Moreover, the three patellar sequences were compared qualitatively, by giving a 1-to-4 score to the images, depending on their yield in the four variables. As for articular cartilage thickness, a statistically significant difference was found between men and women in nearly all measurement sites, the mean values being always higher in men. A statistically significant inverse correlation between cartilage thickness and age was found, in men only, at the three load-bearing regions of the medial femoral condyle. Cartilage surface was irregular and/or its signal intensity altered in 28% of patients at the femoral condyles, while the cartilage of tibial plates exhibited normal surface and homogeneous signal intensity in most cases. The visibility rate of trilaminar cartilage was 82.5% for the medial femoral condyle, 87.5% for the lateral femoral condyle, 70% for the patella, 12.5% for the medial tibial plateau and 14.5% for the lateral tibial plateau. No statistically significant correlation was found between cartilage thickness, surface, signal intensity and visibility and age, sex, and body weight. The GE sequence was the best tool to study cartilage thickness and signal intensity, while the SE T2 sequence was the most accurate one to depict the articular surface and, together with the PD SE sequence, to visualize the trilaminar structure. Our study suggests that articular cartilage surface, thickness, and signal intensity can be studied accurately with SE PD and T2 sequences, combined with a GE T1 sequence.
为研究膝关节透明软骨的磁共振成像(MR)表现,对120名受试者进行了膝关节MRI检查。采用了轴位自旋回波(SE)质子密度(PD)和T2加权像、梯度回波(GE)T1加权像以及GE磁化传递对比(MTC)序列,同时还采用了冠状位SE T1加权像、矢状位SE PD和T2加权像。在髌软骨和股胫关节软骨处,对以下变量进行了研究:厚度、表面情况、信号强度和可视性。此外,对三个髌软骨序列进行了定性比较,根据图像在四个变量方面的表现给予1至4分。关于关节软骨厚度,在几乎所有测量部位,男性和女性之间均存在统计学上的显著差异,男性的平均值总是更高。仅在男性的股骨内侧髁三个负重区域发现软骨厚度与年龄之间存在统计学上的显著负相关。在28%的患者中,股骨髁处的软骨表面不规则和/或信号强度改变,而在大多数情况下,胫骨平台的软骨表面正常且信号强度均匀。股骨内侧髁三层软骨的可视率为82.5%,股骨外侧髁为87.5%,髌骨为70%,胫骨内侧平台为12.5%,胫骨外侧平台为14.5%。未发现软骨厚度、表面情况、信号强度和可视性与年龄、性别和体重之间存在统计学上的显著相关性。GE序列是研究软骨厚度和信号强度的最佳工具,而SE T2序列是描绘关节表面以及与PD SE序列一起可视化三层结构最准确的序列。我们的研究表明,结合GE T1序列,利用SE PD和T2序列可以准确地研究关节软骨的表面、厚度和信号强度。