Mauskop A, Altura B T, Cracco R Q, Altura B M
Department of Neurology, State University of New York, Health Science Center at Brooklyn 11203, USA.
Headache. 1996 Mar;36(3):154-60. doi: 10.1046/j.1526-4610.1996.3603154.x.
Circumstantial evidence points to the possible role of magnesium deficiency in the pathogenesis of headaches and has raised questions about the clinical utility of magnesium as a therapeutic regimen in some headaches.
We evaluated the efficacy of intravenous infusion of 1 gram of magnesium sulfate (MgSO4) for the treatment of patients with headaches and attempted to correlate clinical responses to the basal serum ionized magnesium (IMg2+) level. We also determined if patients with certain headache types exhibit low serum IMg2+ as opposed to total serum magnesium. Using a case-control comparison at an outpatient headache clinic, a consecutive sample of patients presenting with a moderate or severe headache of any type were included in the study. Of the 40 patients in the study (mean age 38.2 +/- 9.4 years; range 14 to 55; 11 men [39.2 +/- 7.3 years] and 29 women [37.8 +/- 10.2 years]), 16 patients had migraines without aura, 9 patients had cluster headaches, 4 patients had chronic tension-type headaches, and 11 had chronic migrainous headaches. Total serum magnesium was measured with atomic absorption spectroscopy and a Kodak Ektachem DT-60. Sensitive ion selective electrodes were utilized to measure serum IMg2+ and ionized calcium (ICa2+); ICa2+/IMg2+ ratios were calculated.
Complete elimination of pain was observed in 80% of the patients within 15 minutes of infusion of MgSO4. No recurrence or worsening of pain was observed within 24 hours in 56% of the patients. Patients treated with MgSO4 observed complete elimination of migraine-associated symptoms such as photophobia and phonophobia as well as nausea. Correlation was noted between immediate and 24-hour responses with the serum IMg2+ levels. Immediate pain relief was observed in 32 (80%) of 40 patients (P < 0.001). In 18. of the 32 patients, pain relief persisted for at least 24 hours (P < 0.005). Of these 18 patients, 16 (89%) had a low serum IMg2+ level. Total magnesium levels in contrast in all subjects were within normal range (0.70-0.99 mmol/L). No side effects were observed, except for a brief flushed feeling. Of the 8 patients with no relief, only 37.5% had a low IMg2+ level. Patients demonstrating no return of headache or associated symptoms within 24 hours of intravenous MgSO4 exhibited the lowest initial basal levels of IMg2+. Non-responders exhibited significantly elevated total magnesium levels compared to responders. Although most subcategories of headache types investigated (ie, migraine, cluster, chronic migrainous) exhibited low serum IMg2+ during headache and prior to intravenous MgSO4, the patients with cluster headaches exhibited the lowest basal levels of IMg2+ (P < 0.01). All headache subjects except for the chronic tension group exhibited rather high serum ICa2+/IMg2+ ratios (P < 0.01, compared to controls).
Intravenous infusion of 1 gram of MgSO4 results in rapid relief of headache pain in patients with low serum IMg2+ levels. Measurement of serum IMg2+ levels may have a practical application in many types of headache patients. Low serum and brain tissue ionized magnesium levels may precipitate headache symptoms in susceptible patients.
间接证据表明镁缺乏在头痛发病机制中可能起作用,并引发了关于镁作为某些头痛治疗方案的临床效用的疑问。
我们评估了静脉输注1克硫酸镁(MgSO4)治疗头痛患者的疗效,并试图将临床反应与基础血清离子化镁(IMg2+)水平相关联。我们还确定了某些头痛类型的患者与血清总镁相比是否表现出血清IMg2+水平较低。在一家门诊头痛诊所进行病例对照比较,纳入了连续样本中出现任何类型中度或重度头痛的患者。在该研究的40名患者中(平均年龄38.2±9.4岁;范围14至55岁;11名男性[39.2±7.3岁]和29名女性[37.8±10.2岁]),16名患者有无先兆偏头痛,9名患者有丛集性头痛,4名患者有慢性紧张型头痛,11名患者有慢性偏头痛性头痛。用原子吸收光谱法和柯达Ektachem DT-60测量血清总镁。使用灵敏的离子选择电极测量血清IMg2+和离子化钙(ICa2+);计算ICa2+/IMg2+比值。
在输注MgSO4的15分钟内,80%的患者疼痛完全消除。56%的患者在24小时内未观察到疼痛复发或加重。接受MgSO4治疗的患者观察到偏头痛相关症状如畏光、畏声以及恶心完全消除。观察到即时和24小时反应与血清IMg2+水平之间存在相关性。40名患者中的32名(80%)即时疼痛缓解(P<0.001)。在这32名患者中的18名中,疼痛缓解持续至少24小时(P<0.005)。在这18名患者中,16名(89%)血清IMg2+水平较低。相比之下,所有受试者的总镁水平均在正常范围内(0.70 - 0.99 mmol/L)。除了短暂的脸红感觉外,未观察到副作用。在8名无缓解的患者中,只有37.5%的患者IMg2+水平较低。在静脉注射MgSO4后24小时内未出现头痛或相关症状复发的患者表现出最低的初始基础IMg2+水平。与有反应者相比,无反应者的总镁水平显著升高。尽管所研究的大多数头痛类型亚组(即偏头痛、丛集性、慢性偏头痛性)在头痛期间和静脉注射MgSO4之前血清IMg2+水平较低,但丛集性头痛患者的基础IMg2+水平最低(P<0.01)。除慢性紧张型组外,所有头痛受试者的血清ICa2+/IMg2+比值均相当高(与对照组相比,P<0.01)。
静脉输注1克MgSO4可使血清IMg2+水平低的患者头痛疼痛迅速缓解。测量血清IMg2+水平可能在许多类型的头痛患者中有实际应用价值。血清和脑组织离子化镁水平低可能在易感患者中引发头痛症状。