Stulberg B N, Singer R, Goldner J, Stulberg J
Cleveland Center for Joint Reconstruction, OH 44115, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1997 Jan(334):116-23.
All patients undergoing uncemented total hip arthroplasty for end stage hip disease related to osteonecrosis of the femoral head were assessed prospectively between November 1983 and October 1992. The results of clinical evaluation using the Harris Hip score and radiographic assessment of fixation were analyzed to identify features of success or failure that may be unique to this population. Four different stem types and 4 different acetabular components were used. Sixty-four patients had 98 hips implanted during the time of the study. The 42 male and 22 female patients averaged 41 years of age (range, 21-69 years). Average followup was 87.3 months (7.3 years; range, 31-134 months). The cause of osteonecrosis was corticosteroids (42 hips), alcohol (27 hips), trauma (5 hips), and other (24 hips). Three patients (5 hips) have died and 4 patients (6 hips) are lost to followup. At last followup 65 of 87 hips (75%) remained radiographically stable and clinically functional, 18 of 87 (21%) have been revised, and 4 were failing (osteolysis). Of the 22 hips with revision or impending failure, 4 were for technical reasons on the femoral side and 18 were for acetabular wear. Patient factors such as weight or underlying disease state did not seem to influence the ability to achieve stable fixation or contribute to accelerated failure. Failures related primarily to problems of first generation devices including accelerated wear of acetabular components, technical issues of femoral component placement (undersizing of components or femoral fracture), and the use of noncircumferentially coated femoral components. Age may be a factor in early failure. This 10-year experience with total hip arthroplasty for the patient with end stage hip disease due to osteonecrosis suggests that uncemented total hip arthroplasty can be applied predictably to this younger, potentially more active patient population.
1983年11月至1992年10月期间,对所有因股骨头坏死导致终末期髋关节疾病而接受非骨水泥型全髋关节置换术的患者进行了前瞻性评估。分析了使用Harris髋关节评分进行的临床评估结果以及固定的影像学评估,以确定该人群可能特有的成功或失败特征。使用了四种不同的股骨柄类型和四种不同的髋臼组件。在研究期间,64例患者的98髋接受了植入。42例男性和22例女性患者的平均年龄为41岁(范围21 - 69岁)。平均随访时间为87.3个月(7.3年;范围31 - 134个月)。股骨头坏死的原因是皮质类固醇(42髋)、酒精(27髋)、创伤(5髋)和其他(24髋)。3例患者(5髋)死亡,4例患者(6髋)失访。在最后一次随访时,87髋中的65髋(75%)在影像学上保持稳定且临床功能良好,87髋中的18髋(21%)进行了翻修,4髋出现失败(骨溶解)。在22例进行翻修或即将失败的髋关节中,4例是由于股骨侧的技术原因,18例是由于髋臼磨损。患者因素如体重或基础疾病状态似乎并未影响获得稳定固定的能力,也未导致加速失败。失败主要与第一代器械的问题有关,包括髋臼组件的加速磨损、股骨组件放置的技术问题(组件尺寸过小或股骨骨折)以及使用非周向涂层的股骨组件。年龄可能是早期失败的一个因素。这10年对因股骨头坏死导致终末期髋关节疾病患者进行全髋关节置换术的经验表明,非骨水泥型全髋关节置换术可以可预测地应用于这个更年轻、可能更活跃的患者群体。