Uchida A, Myoui A, Araki N, Yoshikawa H, Shinto Y, Ueda T
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Osaka University Medical School, Japan.
Cancer. 1997 Jan 15;79(2):411-5.
Since the first trial for chemotherapy in children with osteosarcoma in 1977, the survival rate has gradually improved. Currently, more than 60% of all patients are cured, mainly because of the introduction of intensive chemotherapy using doxorubicin, high dose methotrexate, and cisplatin. The increased survival rates have promoted efforts to improve the quality of survival through the use of limb salvage surgery rather than amputation. Improvements in chemotherapeutic efficacy should result in a more favorable outcome and better function of the affected limb. The current study evaluated factors that influence chemotherapy so that a higher survival rate could be obtained.
Three chemotherapy regimens comprised of doxorubicin, high dose methotrexate, cisplatin, and ifosfamide were retrospectively analyzed in 67 pediatric osteosarcoma patients. Twenty-three patients were treated with chemotherapy comprised of high dose methotrexate and doxorubicin (OOS-A regimen), 25 were treated with OOS-A with the addition of cisplatin (OOS-B), and 19 were treated with OOS-B with the addition of ifosfamide (OOS-C).
The OOS-A regimen was poorest in terms of survival (40.6%) compared with the OOS-B (67.5%) and OOS-C regimens (72.5%) (P < 0.001). There was no significant difference in survival between the OOS-B and OOS-C regimens. In the OOS-B regimen, patients who received a higher relative dose intensity showed a better prognosis.
These findings show that doxorubicin, high dose methotrexate, and cisplatin are the most potent drugs and suggest that it is more important to maintain the dose intensity of the regimen to improve survival rather than add a new drug.
自1977年首次对骨肉瘤患儿进行化疗试验以来,生存率逐渐提高。目前,超过60%的患者被治愈,这主要归功于采用了阿霉素、高剂量甲氨蝶呤和顺铂的强化化疗。生存率的提高促使人们努力通过保肢手术而非截肢来提高生存质量。化疗疗效的提高应能带来更有利的结果和患肢更好的功能。本研究评估了影响化疗的因素,以便获得更高的生存率。
回顾性分析了67例小儿骨肉瘤患者采用的三种化疗方案,这些方案由阿霉素、高剂量甲氨蝶呤、顺铂和异环磷酰胺组成。23例患者接受了由高剂量甲氨蝶呤和阿霉素组成的化疗(OOS-A方案),25例接受了在OOS-A方案基础上加用顺铂的化疗(OOS-B方案),19例接受了在OOS-B方案基础上加用异环磷酰胺的化疗(OOS-C方案)。
与OOS-B方案(67.5%)和OOS-C方案(72.5%)相比,OOS-A方案的生存率最差(40.6%)(P < 0.001)。OOS-B方案和OOS-C方案的生存率无显著差异。在OOS-B方案中,接受相对剂量强度较高的患者预后较好。
这些发现表明阿霉素、高剂量甲氨蝶呤和顺铂是最有效的药物,并提示维持化疗方案的剂量强度对提高生存率比添加新药更重要。