Arribas Blanco J M, Gil Sanz M E, Sanz Rodrigo C, Morón Merchante I, Muñoz-Quirós Aliaga S, Lòpez Romero A, González-Baylín Monje M L, Laguna Delgado L, Verdugo Rosado M
Grupo de Trabajo de Cirugía Menor, Unidad Docente de Medicina de Familia de Madrid.
Med Clin (Barc). 1996 Dec 7;107(20):772-5.
The minor surgery by family physicians increase the primary care competences. The purpose of this work is to prove patients' satisfaction and minor surgery effectiveness practiced by family physicians in health centers with respect to ambulatory's general surgeon.
Case-control retrospective study, comparing dermatological surgical procedures performed by 4 family physicians and 8 3rd-year Family Physician residents with surgical procedures wade made by a surgeon over one a year period. Variables analysed include: descriptive samples homogeneity, surgery effectiveness (waiting time, esthetic results, healing time and number of visits, and histopathologic correlation) and patients' satisfaction (with the waiting time, with the results of surgery and with the physician).
Minor surgical procedures carried out by 146 family physicians and 61 general surgeons were compared, in congruence with the analyzed descriptive homogeneity's parameters. Family physicians average waiting time was the lower, with a mean of 45 days less than the surgeon. Patient's satisfaction with the physician was higher when family physician were involved (p < 0.001); the same could be applied for the waiting time (p < 0.001). There were no significant differences over the effectiveness and patients' satisfaction.
The dermatologic minor surgery by family physician is effective, satisfactory for patients, and has less waiting time. This results justify the introduction of minor surgery in the family physicians office.
家庭医生进行的小型手术可提高初级保健能力。本研究的目的是证明在健康中心,家庭医生实施的小型手术相对于门诊普通外科医生而言,患者满意度及手术效果如何。
病例对照回顾性研究,比较4名家庭医生和8名三年级家庭医生住院医师进行的皮肤科手术与一名外科医生在一年期间实施的手术。分析的变量包括:描述性样本的同质性、手术效果(等待时间、美学效果、愈合时间和就诊次数以及组织病理学相关性)和患者满意度(对等待时间、手术结果和医生的满意度)。
按照分析的描述性同质性参数,对146名家庭医生和61名普通外科医生实施的小型手术进行了比较。家庭医生的平均等待时间更短,平均比外科医生少45天。当由家庭医生实施手术时,患者对医生的满意度更高(p < 0.001);对等待时间的满意度同样如此(p < 0.001)。在手术效果和患者满意度方面没有显著差异。
家庭医生进行的皮肤科小型手术效果良好,患者满意度高,且等待时间更短。这些结果证明了在家庭医生办公室开展小型手术的合理性。