Robinson E, Bartal A, Cohen Y, Haasz R, Mekori T
Cancer. 1977 Sep;40(3):1052-9. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(197709)40:3<1052::aid-cncr2820400313>3.0.co;2-g.
Fifty-one patients with advanced lung cancer were divided at random into two groups. One group of 29 patients received the methanol extraction residue (MER) of Bacille-Calmette-Guerin (BCG) in addition to radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy. The other group of 22 patients was treated by radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy alone. The immune status of the patients was evaluated by skin tests to three recall antigens and KLH and by in vitro lymphocyte stimulation to PHA and three recall antigens. The immune status of both groups was similar before and after conventional treatment. The cutaneous reactivity, as well as the in vitro lymphocyte reactivity, became stronger in the MER-treated group, as compared with the control group. The MER-treated patients had less distant metastases. In a comparable clinical stage the survival in the MER treated group was slightly but not significantly better. This study has shown that MER stimulates the immune response, can be well tolerated and has few side effects. Therefore, MER treatment of patients with minimal tumor load can ethically be done with hope of obtaining better results.
51例晚期肺癌患者被随机分为两组。一组29例患者除接受放疗和/或化疗外,还接受了卡介苗(BCG)的甲醇提取残渣(MER)治疗。另一组22例患者仅接受放疗和/或化疗。通过对三种回忆抗原和钥孔血蓝蛋白(KLH)进行皮肤试验以及对PHA和三种回忆抗原进行体外淋巴细胞刺激来评估患者的免疫状态。两组患者在常规治疗前后的免疫状态相似。与对照组相比,MER治疗组的皮肤反应性以及体外淋巴细胞反应性增强。接受MER治疗的患者远处转移较少。在可比的临床分期中,MER治疗组的生存率略有提高,但无显著差异。本研究表明,MER可刺激免疫反应,耐受性良好且副作用少。因此,从伦理角度出发,对肿瘤负荷最小的患者进行MER治疗有望获得更好的效果。