Huitink J M, Visser F C, Bax J J, van Lingen A, Visser C A
Department of Cardiology, Free University, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Int J Cardiol. 1996 Dec 13;57(3):271-81. doi: 10.1016/s0167-5273(96)02840-9.
Planar reset myocardial thallium-201 chloride (201Tl)/F18-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) imaging has been shown to distinguish between viable and non-viable tissue. Twenty-five patients (60 +/- 9 years) with acute myocardial infarction were studied using this technique within 6 +/- 2 days (T1) after infarction and again after 42 +/- 4 days (T6). Serial assessment of wall motion with 2D-echocardiography was performed to determine the predictive value of radionuclide indices for the course of impaired regional left ventricular function. No revascularization procedure was performed. Segmental 201Tl and FDG uptake was evaluated using circumferential profiles. Echocardiographic wall motion was scored as normal, hypokinetic or akinetic. Myocardial segments were considered non-viable if a match between 201Tl and FDG uptake was present, which is a concordant reduction in 201 Tl and FDG uptake (Group A). Myocardial segments were considered viable if: a mismatch was present between 201Tl and FDG uptake which was defined as a segmental FDG uptake exceeding 201Tl uptake by > or = 20% in a segment with reduced 201Tl uptake (Group B); a normal FDG uptake (> or = 75%) was present without a mismatch pattern in a segment with reduced 201Tl uptake (201Tl < 75% of peak activity) (Group C); a normal 201Tl uptake was present in the area of wall motion abnormality (Group D). Corresponding scintigraphic images obtained at T1 and T6 were compared.
51 segments were normokinetic, 37 were hypokinetic and 6 were akinetic at T1. Of the 63 segments with wall motion abnormalities at T1, 18 regions showed a match (FDG-201Tl < 20%) (Group A). Regional function improved in only one (6%) of these segments. In 19 regions a mismatch was present (FDG-201Tl > 20%) (Group B) of which three (16%) showed spontaneous improvement in function (p = NS vs. matched segments), although recovery varied considerably among patients. Regional function in two segments deteriorated. In 14 regions with reduced 201Tl uptake, FDG uptake was normal (Group C) of which five (36%) were improved after 6 weeks (p < 0.05 vs. match; p = NS vs. mismatched segments). Of the 12 segments with normal 201Tl uptake (Group D), seven (58%) showed improvement in function, whereas five (42%) did not show improvement (p < 0.05 vs. match). In addition, all scintigraphically selected viable segments were grouped (Group B + C + D) and compared with the non-viable segments (Group A). The predictive value of a positive viability test for spontaneous functional improvement was 33%. The predictive value of a negative viability test for lack of functional improvement was 94%.
absence of residual FDG uptake shortly after infarction is associated with irreversible injury, while preservation of metabolic activity identifies segments with variable outcome. Wall motion alone is not a good indicator for the presence of viable tissue. Planar 201Tl/FDG imaging allows early identification of viable but jeopardized tissue and may help select patients who will benefit from aggressive therapy to salvage endangered myocardium.
平面复位心肌氯化铊-201(²⁰¹Tl)/F18-氟脱氧葡萄糖(FDG)成像已被证明可区分存活和非存活组织。对25例急性心肌梗死患者(60±9岁)在梗死后6±2天(T1)使用该技术进行研究,并在42±4天(T6)后再次进行研究。采用二维超声心动图对室壁运动进行连续评估,以确定放射性核素指标对左心室局部功能受损病程的预测价值。未进行血运重建术。使用圆周轮廓评估节段性²⁰¹Tl和FDG摄取。超声心动图室壁运动评分分为正常、运动减弱或运动消失。如果²⁰¹Tl和FDG摄取匹配,即²⁰¹Tl和FDG摄取均一致降低,则心肌节段被认为是非存活的(A组)。如果出现以下情况,心肌节段被认为是存活的:²⁰¹Tl和FDG摄取不匹配,定义为在²⁰¹Tl摄取降低的节段中,节段性FDG摄取超过²⁰¹Tl摄取≥20%(B组);在²⁰¹Tl摄取降低(²⁰¹Tl<峰值活性的75%)的节段中,FDG摄取正常(≥75%)且不存在不匹配模式(C组);在室壁运动异常区域²⁰¹Tl摄取正常(D组)。比较在T1和T6获得的相应闪烁扫描图像。
在T1时,51个节段运动正常,37个节段运动减弱,6个节段运动消失。在T1时存在室壁运动异常的63个节段中,18个区域显示匹配(FDG-²⁰¹Tl<20%)(A组)。这些节段中只有1个(6%)区域功能得到改善。在19个区域存在不匹配(FDG-²⁰¹Tl>20%)(B组),其中3个(16%)区域功能自发改善(与匹配节段相比,P=无显著性差异),尽管患者之间的恢复情况差异很大。2个节段的区域功能恶化。在14个²⁰¹Tl摄取降低的区域,FDG摄取正常(C组),其中5个(36%)在6周后得到改善(与匹配节段相比,P<0.05;与不匹配节段相比,P=无显著性差异)。在12个²⁰¹Tl摄取正常的节段(D组)中,7个(58%)区域功能得到改善,而5个(42%)区域功能未得到改善(与匹配节段相比,P<0.05)。此外,将所有闪烁扫描选择的存活节段归为一组(B+C+D组)并与非存活节段(A组)进行比较。存活试验阳性对自发功能改善的预测价值为33%。存活试验阴性对功能无改善的预测价值为94%。
梗死后不久缺乏残留FDG摄取与不可逆损伤相关,而代谢活性的保留可识别预后各异的节段。仅室壁运动不是存活组织存在的良好指标。平面²⁰¹Tl/FDG成像可早期识别存活但处于危险中的组织,并可能有助于选择将从积极治疗中受益以挽救濒危心肌的患者。