Bauer R L, Venkatachalam H M, Forrester R H, Harris G D, Diehl A K
Department of Medicine, University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio 78284-7879, USA.
Acad Med. 1997 Feb;72(2):147-9. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199702000-00024.
To assess the effect of an ambulatory care experience on medical students' perceptions of internal medicine and their choices of careers (as measured by residency selections).
In 1990-91, the 196 third-year students enrolled in the 12-week internal medicine clerkship at the University of Texas Medical School at San Antonio were randomized to a curriculum that included a three-week ambulatory care component or to a traditional, exclusively inpatient curriculum. The ambulatory curriculum included the evaluation of walk-in-patients, exposure to community internists, and a lecture series. The students' perceptions of internal medicine were surveyed before and after the clerkship. Their career choices were determined by their residency selections at graduation. Data analysis employed chi-square tests, t-tests, and logistic regression.
Of the 196 students, 184 (76 in the ambulatory and 108 in the traditional curricula) provided complete data. The ambulatory care students were somewhat more likely to enter an internal medicine residency (odds ratio = 1.49; 95% CI, 0.72 to 3.09) than were the traditional students. The ambulatory care students' perceptions of internal medicine did not change significantly from before to after the clerkship.
The ambulatory curriculum had a modest but favorable effect on the students' selections of careers in internal medicine, but was not associated with changes in their perceptions of internal medicine.
评估门诊医疗经历对医学生对内科的认知及其职业选择(以住院医师选拔衡量)的影响。
1990 - 1991年,在圣安东尼奥德克萨斯大学医学院参加为期12周内科实习的196名三年级学生被随机分为两组,一组采用包含为期三周门诊医疗内容的课程,另一组采用传统的、仅包含住院治疗内容的课程。门诊课程包括对门诊患者的评估、接触社区内科医生以及一系列讲座。在实习前后对学生对内科的认知进行调查。他们的职业选择由毕业时的住院医师选拔决定。数据分析采用卡方检验、t检验和逻辑回归。
196名学生中,184名(门诊课程组76名,传统课程组108名)提供了完整数据。门诊医疗组学生比传统课程组学生进入内科住院医师培训的可能性略高(优势比 = 1.49;95%可信区间,0.72至3.09)。门诊医疗组学生对内科的认知在实习前后没有显著变化。
门诊课程对学生选择内科职业有适度但积极的影响,但与他们对内科的认知变化无关。