Wright E D, Manoukian J J, Shapiro R S
Department of Otolaryngology, McGill University Faculty of Medicine, Montreal, Quebec.
J Otolaryngol. 1997 Feb;26(1):36-43.
This study was performed to critically evaluate a new cautery technique for adenoidectomy that combines indirect visualization with complete hemostasis, ultimately permitting the surgeon to tailor the procedure to the patient's specific needs.
This prospective study of 138 consecutive adenoidectomy patients of the senior author was carried out at the Montreal Children's Hospital over 17 months. Concurrent adenoidectomy patients of another senior otolaryngologist in our institution as well as cases of the senior author using the conventional cold curettage technique served as controls.
Data were collected preoperatively with respect to indication for surgery and radiologic findings. Operative findings including duration of surgery, concurrent procedures, position of adenoid hypertrophy, and blood loss were also recorded. Postoperative complications such as hemorrhage, infection, dehydration, as well as the incidence of velopharyngeal insufficiency and nasopharyngeal stenosis were also recorded up to 1 year from the date of surgery. The operative technique involves indirect visualization of the nasopharynx with a laryngeal mirror combined with cautery-liquefaction and suction ablation of the adenoid tissue.
Our results demonstrate a significant reduction in blood loss as well as a reduction in operative time. There was a low incidence of postoperative infection, no patients required a return to the operating room for hemostasis, and there were no cases of recurrent adenoid hypertrophy. There was no detectable difference in the incidence of postoperative complications.
We conclude that this technique is safe and time-efficient, with the advantages of excellent visualization and essentially no operative blood loss.
本研究旨在严格评估一种新的腺样体切除术烧灼技术,该技术将间接可视化与完全止血相结合,最终使外科医生能够根据患者的具体需求调整手术方式。
这项前瞻性研究对资深作者连续138例腺样体切除术患者进行,在蒙特利尔儿童医院进行了17个月。本机构另一位资深耳鼻喉科医生同期进行腺样体切除术的患者以及资深作者使用传统冷刮除技术的病例作为对照。
术前收集有关手术指征和影像学检查结果的数据。还记录手术结果,包括手术时间、同期手术、腺样体肥大位置和失血量。术后并发症如出血、感染、脱水以及腭咽功能不全和鼻咽狭窄的发生率也在手术后1年内进行记录。手术技术包括用喉镜间接观察鼻咽部,同时对腺样体组织进行烧灼液化和抽吸消融。
我们的结果表明失血量显著减少,手术时间缩短。术后感染发生率低,无患者因止血需要返回手术室,也无复发性腺样体肥大病例。术后并发症发生率无明显差异。
我们得出结论,该技术安全且省时,具有可视化效果极佳且基本无术中失血的优点。