Gommerman S L, Hodge M M
Capital Health Authority, Public Health Services, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Int J Orofacial Myology. 1995 Nov;21:9-22.
This study investigated the effectiveness of oral myofunctional therapy in eliminating a 16 year-old girl's tongue thrust swallowing pattern and mild sibilant distortion. An ABC design was used where Phase A had eight baseline sessions (no treatment), Phase B had 14 oral myofunctional therapy sessions, and Phase C had four articulation treatment sessions. Dependent measures of swallowing and sibilant production were obtained in each session. A third dependent variable, labial diadochokinetic rate, was also measured each session and served as a control for maturation. Oral myofunctional therapy was shown to be effective in eliminating the tongue thrust swallowing pattern of this subject, but not her sibilant distortion. However, her sibilant distortion reduced after one articulation treatment session and was maintained at negligible levels over the next three treatment sessions. As expected, labial diadochokinetic rate remained stable across the three phases. At the conclusion of Phase C, two bi-weekly home visits revealed that the subject had maintained and generalized her new swallowing pattern. Measures obtained six months after completion of Phase C indicated that the subject had maintained her new swallowing and speech production behaviors. The subject's maximal tongue strength and endurance were below expected normal values at the initiation of the study and increased during the study. Her tongue endurance appeared more sensitive to the effects of oral myofunctional training than tongue strength and, unlike tongue strength, tongue endurance decreased in the six month period following completion of the study.
本研究调查了口腔肌功能治疗消除一名16岁女孩的吐舌吞咽模式和轻度咝音扭曲的有效性。采用ABC设计,其中A阶段有8次基线期治疗(无治疗),B阶段有14次口腔肌功能治疗,C阶段有4次发音治疗。在每个阶段获取吞咽和咝音产生的相关测量数据。第三个相关变量,即唇运动速率,也在每个阶段进行测量,并作为成熟度的对照指标。结果表明,口腔肌功能治疗能有效消除该受试者的吐舌吞咽模式,但不能消除其咝音扭曲。然而,经过一次发音治疗后,她的咝音扭曲有所减轻,并在接下来的三次治疗中维持在可忽略不计的水平。正如预期的那样,唇运动速率在三个阶段中保持稳定。在C阶段结束时,两次每两周一次的家访显示该受试者保持并泛化了她新的吞咽模式。在C阶段完成六个月后获得的测量数据表明,该受试者保持了她新的吞咽和言语产生行为。在研究开始时,该受试者的最大舌力量和耐力低于预期正常值,并且在研究期间有所增加。她的舌耐力似乎比舌力量对口腔肌功能训练的效果更敏感,并且与舌力量不同,在研究完成后的六个月内舌耐力下降了。