Lai C H, Hsueh S, Chang T C, Tseng C J, Huang K G, Chou H H, Chen S M, Chang M F, Shum H C
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Tao-Yuan, Taiwan.
Gynecol Oncol. 1997 Mar;64(3):456-62. doi: 10.1006/gyno.1996.4603.
All patients with bulky (> or =4 cm) Stage Ib or IIa cervical carcinoma treated at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital between August 1988 and December 1991 using a strategy of neoadjuvant chemotherapy with cisplatin, vincristine, and bleomycin and radical hysterectomy were reviewed. Fifty-nine evaluable patients received 1 to 3 courses of chemotherapy, and 51 underwent subsequent hysterectomy. The remaining 8 patients, not completing planned surgery, were treated with definitive radiotherapy. The overall clinical response rate was 81.4% (48/59) with 18.6% complete response. Clinical response to chemotherapy was not different by stage, histologic type, tumor size, level of squamous cell carcinoma antigen, or DNA ploidy. However, tumors with DNA indices (DI) greater than 1.3 were associated with higher clinical response rates than tumors with DI < or = 1.3 (P = 0.043). Histologically proven pelvic node metastases was noted in 18.5% (10/54) who had laparotomy. Concomitant pregnancy and more than one node metastases had significant adverse influence on recurrence and death. The 5-year survival rate of those patients who received hysterectomy was 80.3%, while only 1 of the 8 patients without hysterectomy survived. Of the 7 patients received hysterectomy despite clinical poor response, only 2 had node metastases and 3 died, whereas all the 4 patients deterred hysterectomy for poor response died. This study demonstrates the value of DNA flow cytometry in predicting chemosensitivity. However, with a DI cutoff at 1.3, only 29.2% patients could be selected. Further studies are necessary to find additional indicators that predict histological response to select better candidates for this approach and to determine optimal adjunctive treatment in case that poor prognostic features are found.
回顾了1988年8月至1991年12月间在长庚纪念医院接受治疗的所有Ib期或IIa期宫颈癌(肿块≥4 cm)患者,这些患者采用顺铂、长春新碱和博来霉素新辅助化疗及根治性子宫切除术的策略。59例可评估患者接受了1至3个疗程的化疗,51例随后接受了子宫切除术。其余8例未完成计划手术的患者接受了根治性放疗。总体临床缓解率为81.4%(48/59),完全缓解率为18.6%。化疗的临床反应在分期、组织学类型、肿瘤大小、鳞状细胞癌抗原水平或DNA倍体方面无差异。然而,DNA指数(DI)大于1.3的肿瘤比DI≤1.3的肿瘤临床缓解率更高(P = 0.043)。经组织学证实,接受剖腹手术的患者中有18.5%(10/54)存在盆腔淋巴结转移。合并妊娠和多个淋巴结转移对复发和死亡有显著不利影响。接受子宫切除术的患者5年生存率为80.3%,而8例未接受子宫切除术的患者中只有1例存活。在7例尽管临床反应不佳仍接受子宫切除术的患者中,只有2例有淋巴结转移,3例死亡,而所有4例因反应不佳而未接受子宫切除术的患者均死亡。本研究证明了DNA流式细胞术在预测化疗敏感性方面的价值。然而,以DI截止值1.3进行筛选时,只有29.2%的患者可被选中。有必要进一步研究以找到其他预测组织学反应的指标,从而为该方法选择更好的候选者,并在发现预后不良特征时确定最佳辅助治疗方案。