Caballero M D, Amigo M L, Hernández J M, Vazquez L, del Cañizo C, Gonzalez M, García R, San Miguel J F
Servicio de Hematología, Hospital Universitario de Salamanca, Spain.
Ann Hematol. 1997 Feb;74(2):79-82. doi: 10.1007/s002770050261.
Mini-BEAM and ESHAP are two non-cross-resistant salvage regimens that have been used separately in patients with lymphoma. The aim of the present study was to investigate the efficacy of the combination of these two regimens, administered in alternating cycles, as salvage therapy for refractory non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) patients. A total of 28 patients were included in the study: 14 patients were primary refractory, seven were partial responders, and seven were in relapse. The alternating cycles of mini-BEAM and ESHAP were given until there was maximum response or progression. The overall response rate to mini-BEAM/ESHAP was 39%; 25% of patients achieved a complete response and 14% a partial response. Nevertheless, it should be noted that none of the primary refractory patients responded to this protocol. Nine of the 11 patients who responded to mini-BEAM/ESHAP were consolidated with autologous transplantation using BEAM as a conditioning regimen. The survival at 3 years in this group of 11 patients who responded to the salvage regimen is 64%, with a disease-free survival of 67% at 2 years. No major toxic effects were observed with mini-BEAM/ESHAP. Myelosuppression was the most frequent complication, especially with the mini-BEAM cycles. Other toxicities were infrequent and no treatment-related deaths were observed. These results suggest that alternating mini-BEAM/ESHAP chemotherapy is a safe regimen that is effective in partial responders or relapsing patients with NHL who have sensitive disease, but not in primary refractory patients. Moreover, although this therapy has a potential advantage, combining as it does two non-cross-resistant regimens, it does not seem superior to ESHAP alone.
Mini-BEAM和ESHAP是两种无交叉耐药性的挽救方案,已分别用于淋巴瘤患者。本研究的目的是探讨将这两种方案交替循环使用作为难治性非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)患者挽救治疗的疗效。共有28例患者纳入研究:14例为原发性难治性患者,7例为部分缓解者,7例为复发患者。给予Mini-BEAM和ESHAP交替循环治疗,直至出现最大反应或病情进展。Mini-BEAM/ESHAP的总缓解率为39%;25%的患者达到完全缓解,14%的患者达到部分缓解。然而,应当指出的是,原发性难治性患者对该方案均无反应。对Mini-BEAM/ESHAP有反应的11例患者中有9例采用BEAM作为预处理方案进行自体移植巩固治疗。这11例对挽救方案有反应的患者3年生存率为64%,2年无病生存率为67%。未观察到Mini-BEAM/ESHAP有严重毒性作用。骨髓抑制是最常见的并发症,尤其是在Mini-BEAM周期。其他毒性反应较少见,未观察到与治疗相关的死亡。这些结果表明,交替使用Mini-BEAM/ESHAP化疗是一种安全的方案,对部分缓解或复发的敏感疾病NHL患者有效,但对原发性难治性患者无效。此外,尽管这种疗法有潜在优势,因为它结合了两种无交叉耐药性的方案,但似乎并不优于单独使用ESHAP。