Carp H J, Toder V, Torchinsky A, Portuguese S, Lipitz S, Gazit E, Mashiach S
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Tel Aviv, Israel.
Hum Reprod. 1997 Feb;12(2):250-5. doi: 10.1093/humrep/12.2.250.
Rather than investigate whether paternal leukocyte immunization improves the live birth rate in women with three or more abortions, we analysed the results of patients expected to have a poor outcome in a subsequent pregnancy if untreated, i.e. women with five or more abortions and no anti-paternal complement-dependent antibody (APCA) at initial testing. The analysis included the results of patients treated by us over the last 8 years and the results of randomized and non-randomized trials reported by the Recurrent Miscarriage Immunotherapy Trialists Group. Patients with a previous live birth were classified into two groups: secondary aborters if there was an initial live birth followed by miscarriages, or tertiary aborters if there were miscarriages followed by a live birth and at least three subsequent miscarriages. The results were evaluated separately for primary, secondary and tertiary aborters who demonstrated APCA activity as a result of immunization. The 107 primary aborters had double the live birth rate if immunized, with an overall benefit of 31%. The 45 tertiary aborters had an almost 3-fold increase in the live birth rate, with an absolute benefit of 50%. The number of patients needed to treat to achieve one extra live birth was three to four primary aborters or two tertiary aborters. Immunization had little beneficial effect in secondary aborters but was effective in preventing abortion in primary or tertiary aborters with five or more abortions.
我们没有研究父亲白细胞免疫是否能提高有三次或更多次流产史女性的活产率,而是分析了那些若不治疗后续妊娠结局可能较差的患者的结果,即有五次或更多次流产史且初次检测时无抗父亲补体依赖抗体(APCA)的女性。分析纳入了我们在过去8年中治疗的患者结果以及复发性流产免疫治疗试验组报告的随机和非随机试验结果。有过活产史的患者分为两组:如果初次活产后接着发生流产则为继发性流产者;如果流产后接着活产且随后至少有三次流产则为三次性流产者。对因免疫而表现出APCA活性的原发性、继发性和三次性流产者的结果分别进行评估。107名原发性流产者免疫后活产率翻倍,总体获益为31%。45名三次性流产者活产率几乎提高了3倍,绝对获益为50%。要多获得一次活产需要治疗的患者数量为三到四名原发性流产者或两名三次性流产者。免疫对继发性流产者几乎没有有益效果,但对有五次或更多次流产史的原发性或三次性流产者预防流产有效。