Ravdin L D, Perrine K, Haywood C S, Gershengorn J, Nelson P K, Devinsky O
New York Hospital, Cornell Medical Center, New York, USA.
Brain Cogn. 1997 Mar;33(2):151-60. doi: 10.1006/brcg.1997.0889.
There is considerable variability among epilepsy centers in the methods and interpretations of the intracarotid amobarbital procedure. Prominent among these differences is the determination of language representation and assessment of language functions. Some centers rely on speech arrest following amobarbital injection as a marker for language representation, whereas other centers examine verbal output for the presence of aphasic errors. The present study assessed the pattern of language recovery following amobarbital injection in epilepsy patients who were candidates for temporal lobectomy. Language recovery from dominant hemisphere injection (left or right) followed a stereotypical progression, with 71.8% of patients showing return of vocalization followed by return of naming and comprehension. Repetition deficits with paraphasic errors persisted the longest (mean = 12'30"), with a conduction aphasia persisting after the acute global aphasia resolved. Although two patients interpreted as left hemisphere language dominant were mute following right hemisphere injection, all language functions were intact immediately upon resumption of vocalization and they showed no other signs of aphasia such as paraphasias or anomia. Possible explanations for serial language recovery and persistent conduction aphasia are discussed. These findings have significant implications for the determination of cerebral language dominance.
在癫痫中心,颈动脉注射异戊巴比妥试验的方法和解读存在相当大的差异。这些差异中突出的是语言表征的确定和语言功能的评估。一些中心将异戊巴比妥注射后言语停止作为语言表征的标志,而其他中心则检查言语输出中是否存在失语错误。本研究评估了颞叶切除术候选癫痫患者异戊巴比妥注射后的语言恢复模式。优势半球注射(左或右)后的语言恢复遵循一种刻板的进展模式,71.8%的患者发声恢复,随后是命名和理解能力的恢复。伴有错语的复述缺陷持续时间最长(平均 = 12分30秒),在急性完全性失语症消退后传导性失语仍持续存在。尽管两名被认为左半球为语言优势半球的患者在右半球注射后出现沉默,但发声恢复后所有语言功能立即完好无损,且未表现出其他失语迹象,如错语或命名障碍。文中讨论了语言顺序恢复和持续性传导性失语的可能解释。这些发现对大脑语言优势的确定具有重要意义。