O'Quinn P R, Knabe D A, Gregg E J, Lusas E W
Department of Animal Science, Texas A&M University, College Station 77843, USA.
J Anim Sci. 1997 Mar;75(3):714-9. doi: 10.2527/1997.753714x.
Three experiments were conducted to compare the nutritional value of soybean meal produced by extraction with 95% isopropyl alcohol (IPA) or hexane (HEX) for swine. The same batch of soybeans and the same processing equipment were used to produce both soybean meals. Analyzed contents of the IPA and HEX meals were, respectively: CP, 48.7, 47.0%; lysine, 3.11, 3.06%; urease, .24, .13 delta pH. In Exp. 1, two soybean meals and dietary lysine at .90 or 1.25% were used in a 2 x 2 factorial arrangement of treatments. Corn-based diets were fed to 32-d-old pigs for 26 d. There were no dietary lysine x soybean meal interactions (P > or = .35). Increasing dietary lysine increased (P < .001) ADG and gain/ feed, but soybean meal source did not affect performance. In Exp. 2, the nutritional value of HEX and IPA meals were evaluated in a N balance study using 34-kg barrows and isonitrogenous corn-based diets containing equal N from either HEX or IPA. Apparent total tract N and DM digestibility were similar for both diets. Nitrogen retention (14.4 vs 13.7 g/d, P < .10) and apparent biological value (56.5 vs 54.5%, P < .05) were slightly higher for HEX than for IPA. The effect of feeding HEX and IPA meals on morphological changes of small intestine in pigs weaned at 21 d of age was investigated in the last experiment. At 28 d of age, weaned pigs that were fed diets containing either HEX or IPA and unweaned control pigs were killed for the examination. Villus height and lamina propria depth at the duodenum were similar among all treatments. At the jejunum, weaned pigs had smaller (P < .05) villus height and greater lamina propria depths (P < .001) than unweaned pigs. Dietary soybean meal source did not affect villus height, but lamina propria depth was less (P < .10) for pigs fed IPA. The results of these experiments indicate that soybean meals produced using IPA or HEX as the solvent have equal nutritional value for swine.
进行了三项试验,比较用95%异丙醇(IPA)或己烷(HEX)浸提生产的豆粕对猪的营养价值。同一批大豆和相同的加工设备用于生产这两种豆粕。IPA豆粕和HEX豆粕的分析成分分别为:粗蛋白48.7%、47.0%;赖氨酸3.11%、3.06%;脲酶,pH值变化0.24、0.13。在试验1中,两种豆粕和日粮赖氨酸水平分别为0.90%或1.25%,采用2×2析因处理设计。以玉米为基础的日粮饲喂32日龄仔猪26天。日粮赖氨酸×豆粕之间不存在互作效应(P≥0.35)。提高日粮赖氨酸水平可提高(P<0.001)平均日增重和料重比,但豆粕来源对生产性能无影响。在试验2中,采用34千克的阉公猪,在氮平衡研究中评估HEX豆粕和IPA豆粕的营养价值,使用含等量氮(分别来自HEX或IPA)的等氮玉米基础日粮。两种日粮的表观全肠道氮和干物质消化率相似。HEX豆粕组的氮保留量(14.4对13.7克/天,P<0.10)和表观生物学价值(56.5%对54.5%,P<0.05)略高于IPA豆粕组。在最后一项试验中,研究了饲喂HEX豆粕和IPA豆粕对21日龄断奶仔猪小肠形态变化的影响。在28日龄时,处死饲喂含HEX或IPA日粮的断奶仔猪和未断奶对照仔猪进行检查。所有处理组十二指肠的绒毛高度和固有层深度相似。在空肠,断奶仔猪的绒毛高度比未断奶仔猪小(P<0.05),固有层深度比未断奶仔猪大(P<0.001)。日粮豆粕来源不影响绒毛高度,但饲喂IPA豆粕的仔猪固有层深度较小(P<0.10)。这些试验结果表明,以IPA或HEX作为溶剂生产的豆粕对猪具有同等营养价值。