[Accelerated hyperfractionated simultaneous radiochemotherapy in advanced head-neck carcinomas in comparison: split course and concomitant boost concept].

PATIENTS

Between 1989 and 1992, 38 patients with advanced squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck were treated by an accelerated hyperfractionated split-course radiochemotherapy (SCRC). This therapy was carried out at the ENT department and department of radiooncology of the University of Heidelberg. Within 51 days, 70.2 Gy were applied in three courses. In every course, simultaneous chemotherapy with cisplatin (60 mg/m2/week)/5 Fu (bolus: 350 mg/m2/d)/Leucovorin (bolus: 50 mg/m2 + 100 mg/m2/24 h) was carried out. Between 1992 and 1994, 50 patients suffering from advanced head and neck cancer (stage III, V) were also treated with an accelerated hyperfractionated concomitant-boost radiochemotherapy (CBRC) at the same departments. A total dose of 66 Gy, was applied within 33 days. The patients were also treated with simultaneous chemotherapy with carboplatin (70 mg/m2/24 h) in the first and fifth week.

RESULTS

In about 50% of the patients treated with SCRC, the therapy was more than 10 days longer than the scheduled period. The lack of compliance due to toxicity was considered as one of the main reasons for this delay. After the first course of SCRC, eight of 38 patients showed mucositis of the upper aerodigestive tract (WHO grade > 3); after the second course, 11 of 38 patients; and after the third course, 15 of 38 patients. Fifty-two percent of the patients developed emesis, 10% leucopenia < 1 nl, 10% nephrotoxicity, 3% pancreatitis, 3% thrombosis, 3% gastritis, and 3% auditory threshold shifts of about more than 10 dB. In about 7.5% of the patients treated with CBRC, the therapy was more than 10 days longer than the scheduled period. The mucositis of the upper aerodigestive tract (50% of the patients showed WHO-grade > 3) was considered to be the main reason for this. In four patients a neutropenia < 1 nl was detected, in one patient anemia < 7 g/dl and n 33 patients thrombocytopenia < 100/nl.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, the concomitant boost radiochemotherapy showed a lower toxicity and higher acceptance than the split-course radiochemotherapy. This is documented in lower protocol delays and better results in the two-years survival time in case of concomitant boost radiotherapy.